Species similarity of wild avian populations containing parasitic flatworms
Analysis of the distribution of bird populations containing flatworms according to
three national parks showed that they decreased in the following order: Xuan Son >
Tam Dao > Cat Ba. They were found 46.97% > 28.79% > 24.24% of a total of sixty-six
bird specimens, respectively (Tables 2-4). The figures show that there are clear
differences in the number of birds containing flatworms between the Xuan Son National
Park, in comparison with Tam Dao and Cat Ba National Parks, 31 vs. 19 and 16,
respectively.
Figure 1 showed that species composition similarities between the three studied
national parks are not high, ranging from 14.02% to 34.03%. The highest species
composition similarity was registered between Xuan Son National Park and Cat Ba
National Park, reaching 34.03%. The three common species between them are
Allophoixus pallidus, Macronous gularis, Cyornis bayumas (13.63% of total species
number).
Tam Dao National Park has a distinct difference in bird species composition
compared to the two above national parks. Particularly, species composition similarity
between Tam Dao National Park compared to Xuan Son and Cat Ba National Parks,
reaching only 16.01%. Specifically, only just three out of twenty-two avian species
identified, accounting for 13.63% of the total species number, are found common to
both Xuan Son and Tam Dao National Parks, namely Allophoixus pallidus, Pellorneum
tickelli and Alcippe morrisonia. Only the one avian species, Allophoixus pallidus,
accounting for 4.54% of the total species number, was found common to the Tam Dao
and Cat Ba National Parks. This is also the only species found in all three national parks
(Xuan Son, Tam Dao, and Cat Ba National Parks).
The data obtained on the highest bird species composition similarity between Xuan
Son National Park of northwest mountainous region and Cat Ba National Park of Hong
River Delta region, and their three common species containing flatworm, and one bird
species, namely Allophoixus pallidus, found in all three studied national parks, are very
significant from a parasitological point of view. These are important factors that should
be considered when assessing the potential for transmission and spread of parasitic
flatworms and pathogens through bird populations, bats, and possibly oribatid mites as well.
9 trang |
Chia sẻ: hachi492 | Lượt xem: 7 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem nội dung tài liệu A role of wild bird population in the transmission of parasitic flatworms (platyhelminthes: cestoidea and trematodea) in Vietnam’s forest, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
99
HNUE JOURNAL OF SCIENCE DOI: 10.18173/2354-1059.2020-0053
Natural Sciences 2020, Volume 65, Issue 10, pp. 99-107
This paper is available online at
A ROLE OF WILD BIRD POPULATION IN THE TRANSMISSION
OF PARASITIC FLATWORMS (PLATYHELMINTHES: CESTOIDEA
AND TREMATODEA) IN VIETNAM’S FOREST
Georgiev B. Boyko1, Mariaux Jean2, Vasileva P. Gergana1, Nguyen Quoc Huy3
and Vu Quang Manh4*
1Institute of Biodiversity and Ecosystem Research, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, Bulgaria
2Natural History Museum, Geneva, Switzerland
3Institute of Ecology and Works Protection Hanoi
4Center for Biodiversity Resources Education & Development,
Hanoi National University of Education
Abstract. The study aimed to evaluate the role of transmitting flatworms
(Cestoidea and Trematodea) of wild bird populations in three national parks of
Vietnam: Xuan Son in the Northwest mountainous region, Tam Dao in the
Northeast mountainous region, and Cat Ba in the Hong River Delta region.
Twenty-two wild avian species of 10 families were found to contain parasitic
flatworms. According to the number of avian species containing parasitic
flatworms, bird families are ranking: Timaliidae recorded with 7 species >
Leiothrichidae and Nectariniidae both with 3 species > Pycononotidae and
Muscicapidae both with 2 species > Vireonidae, Sylvidae, Picidae, Cisticolidae and
Cettiidae with 1 species. According to sex, avian populations containing parasitic
flatworms decrease in the order: females accounting for 43.94% of the total
individuals > males for 39.40% > juveniles for 16.66%. Three bird species
containing flatworms A. pallidus, M. gularis and C. bayumas were found in two of
the studied national parks, among them, only the first species was found common
to all three studied national parks. They are vectors of high significance from a
parasitological point of view.
Keywords: wild birds, transmitting parasitic flatworms, national park, Xuan Son,
Tam Dao, Cat Ba.
1. Introduction
Vietnam is a country with high biodiversity and a rich forest ecosystem, containing
many endemic genetic resources as well as transitional genetic ones. However, like
several countries with rapid economic and social growth, Vietnam is facing the risk of
biodiversity degradation and ecological imbalance. Especially, in the era of
globalization, the problem of transmitting and spreading diseases and parasites through
Received October 16, 2020. Revised October 23, 2020. Accepted October 30, 2020.
Georgiev B. Boyko, Mariaux Jean, Vasileva P. Gergana, Nguyen Quoc Huy and Vu Quang Manh
100
Corresponding author: Vu Quang Manh, e-mail address: vqmanh@gmail.com
bird and animal hosts, related to the soil environment, are a big challenge. Soil-
transmitted helminthes are transmitted by eggs passing in the faeces of infected people.
In conditions that lack adequate sanitation, these eggs contaminate the soil. Soil-
transmitted helminthes, including flatworms (Platyhelminthes: Cestoidea and
Trematodea), infections are caused by different species of parasitic worms (Krivolutsky
et al. 1997, Le et al. 2003, Gray et al. 2010, WHO 2020) [1-4]. A recent analysis by
Nguyen Quynh Huong et al. (2020) suggested not only the mixing of animal excreta in
the environment but also the interspecies transmission of corona viruses, as both bat and
avian coronaviruses were detected in rodent feces on wildlife farms [5].
The analysis data for this study is based on field survey data of the international
program Planetary Biodiversity Inventory: A survey of the flatworms (Cestoidea and
Trematodea) from the vertebrate bowels of the Earth (2008-2014), funded by the United
States National Science Foundation. One of the objectives of the program is to carry out
parasitological surveys of vertebrate hosts, including birds, in areas and types of
habitats, which have never been or have insufficiently been studied from a
parasitological point of view. The envisaged results of such surveys are to find and
describe unknown species of cestode parasites, thus enriching the knowledge on the
species diversity (Caira et al. 2018) [6].
The present study aimed to evaluate the role of containing and transmitting
flatworms (Cestoidea and Trematodea) in wild bird populations in Vietnam’s forests.
2. Content
2.1. Materials and methods
* Study region
In June and July of 2014, we studied the diversity of parasitic flatworms Cestoidea
and Trematodea in bird populations in three types of habitats, which have been poorly
studied from parasitological a point of view [7, 8]. The study forests were three national
parks including Xuan Son National Park of Phu Tho province, from Northwest
mountainous region of Vietnam, 21007.87’ N - 104057.20’ E; Tam Dao National Park of
Vinh Phuc province, from Northeast mountainous region, 21° 28.41' - 105° 38.35' E;
and Cat Ba National Park, the island belonging to Hai Phong city, from Hong River
Delta region, 20° 47.90’ N - 107° 00.29’’ E [9].
* Collecting materials
At each of these three national parks, we stayed for 5 - 6 days, for field studies.
Birds were collected from three habitat types, including scrublands, forested areas, and
wetlands. Birds were collected by using ornithological mist-nets. We studied a number
of individuals of each bird species occurring in the area. Therefore, the numbers of the
birds, which were collected during the single collecting activity, is too small to affect
local populations. It is entirely in the frames of natural mortality. This study has been
authorized by the Vietnamese governing body. The bird species of interest were
examined for the presence of gastrointestinal parasites and ectoparasites after euthanasia
in chloroform. The contents of intestines will be studied under a stereomicroscope.
A role of wild bird population in the transmission of parasitic flatworms (Platyhelminthes
101
Some individuals of each bird species occurring in the area were also studied. Bird’s
bodies were processed for deposition in the zoological collection of the CEBRED,
Hanoi National University of Education. Parasites - flatworms were isolated from the
intestinal contents, fixed, and conserved in ethanol for subsequent laboratory processing
and examination. Then, they were carried out in our laboratories in Vietnam, Bulgaria,
and Switzerland.
* Classification and species identification
The classification and species identification of birds follow mainly to Vo & Nguyen
(1999), Richard and Le (2018) [10, 11]. Parasites were isolated from the intestinal
contents, fixed, and conserved in ethanol for subsequent laboratory processing and
examination. They were carried out in the laboratories in Vietnam, Bulgaria, and
Switzerland. The classification and species identification of flatworms follow mainly
Nguyen (1979), Khalil et al. (1994), Nguyen (1995) [12, 13, 14].
* Data analysis
For data analysis used are the Microsoft Office Excel 2010, and the multivariate
ecological research version 6. PRIMER 6 is a collection of specialist routines for
analyzing species or sample abundance. This method is normally used for ecological
and environmental studies [15, 16]. Species similarity index Bray-Curtis (BCjk):
ij ik
jk
ij ik
n n
BC
(n n )
−
=
+
where BCjk is species similarity between studied forests;
nik is the number of k species recorded in i samples;
nij is the number of j species recorded in i samples.
Hierarchical cluster analysis of bird species similaritíes between the studied
national parks is calculated and based on Bray-Curtis indices [15, 16].
2.2. Results and discussions
2.2.1. Species composition of wild avian populations containing parasitic flatworms
A parasitological survey of vertebrates including birds and bats and invertebrates
including oribatid mites (Acari: Oribatida) in three national parks have insufficiently
been studied from a parasitological point of view [1, 7, 8, 17-19]. Table 1 presents a
species composition of wild avian populations found to contain parasitic flatworms in
their intestines. Introduced are also the distribution characteristics of birds as well as
their sex and age according to the three studied national parks.
Table 1. Avian species composition containing parasitic flatworms
in three national parks
Distribution’s
characteristics
Scientific names
Distribution according to national parks Notice
Xuan Son
- Northwest
Mountainous
region
Tam Dao
- Northeast
Mountainous
region
Cat Ba
- Hong River
Delta region
Georgiev B. Boyko, Mariaux Jean, Vasileva P. Gergana, Nguyen Quoc Huy and Vu Quang Manh
102
I. Pycononotidae
1. Allophoixus
pallidus
M M, F M, M, M, F,
F,
2. Hemixos
castanonotus
M, M, F
II. Vireonidae
3. Erpornis
zantholeuca
M, F
III. Timallidae
4. Pomatorhinus
ruficollis
M
5. Pellorneum tickell M, F, (?) F (?) Sex not
clear.
Accounted as a
juvenile.
6. Pellorneum
ruficeps
F
7. Stachyris nigriceps M, F, J
8. Stachyris striolata M, F
9. Macronous gularis
M, M, M, F,
F, F, F
M, F, F, F,
F, F, J, F, F
10. Napothera
brevicaudata
M
IV. Leiothrichidae
11. Alcippe
morrisonia
(?) M, M, M, J,
J
(?) Sex not
clear.
Accounted as a
juvenile.
12. Ianthocincla
chinensis (*)
F (*) Species were
firstly
discovered in
Vietnam. To be
investigated
more.
13. Alcippe
rufogularis
M, M, M, F,
F, (?)
(?) Sex not
clear.
A role of wild bird population in the transmission of parasitic flatworms (Platyhelminthes
103
Accounted as a
juvenile.
V. Sylvidae
14. Neosuthora
davidianus
M, F
VI. Muscicapidae
15. Cyornis bayumas
F, J F
16. Luscinia cyane F
VII. Nectariniidae
17. Aethopyga
christinae
J
18. Arachnothera
longirostra
M, F
19. Arachnothera
magna
F
VIII. Picidae
20. Sasia ochracea
(?) (?) Sex not
clear.
Accounted as a
juvenile.
IX. Cisticolidae
21. Orthotomus
atrogularis
M
X. Cettiidae
22. Abroscopus
superciliaris
(?) (?) Sex not
clear.
Accounted as a
juvenile.
Total: 10 families and
22 species
11 M-13 F-
7 J
= 31 bird
specimens
10 M -6 F -
3 J
= 19 bird
specimens
5 M -10 F -
1 J
= 16 bird
specimens
Total: 26 M -29
F -11 J
= 66 bird
specimens
Legend. Bird sex: F. Female, M. Male, J. Juvenile, (?). Sex not clear.
Georgiev B. Boyko, Mariaux Jean, Vasileva P. Gergana, Nguyen Quoc Huy and Vu Quang Manh
104
During the study, sixty-six avian individuals have been recorded to contain parasitic
flatworms in their intestines. They belong to 22 species of 10 avian families. Analysis
done showed that according to the number of species containing parasitic flatworms, the
avian families are ranked in the following descending order: Timaliidae was recorded
with 7 species > Leiothrichidae and Nectariniidae both with 3 species > Pycononotidae
and Muscicapidae both with 2 species. The remaining five families including
Vireonidae, Sylvidae, Picidae, Cisticolidae, and Cettiidae, all were recorded with 1
species (Table 1).
2.2.2. Sex composition of wild avian populations containing parasitic flatworms
Tables 2-4 presents characteristics of bird populations containing flatworms by
their sex in the three studied national parks.
Table 2. The avian composition containing parasitic flatworms
according to each park
Bird sex
National park
Total
Xuan Son Tam Dao Cat Ba
Male 11 (42.31%) 10 (38.46%) 05 (19.23 %) 26 (100%)
Female 13 (44.83%) 06 (20.69%) 10 (34.48%) 29 (100%)
Juvenile 07 (63.64%) 03 (27.27%) 01 (9.09%) 11 (100%)
Table 3. The avian composition containing parasitic flatworms
according to each sex
National Park
Bird sex
Total
Male Female Juvenile
Xuan Son 11 (35.48%) 13 (41.97%) 07 (22.58%) 31 (100%)
Tam Dao 10 (52.63%) 06 (31.58%) 03 (15.79%) 19 (100%)
Cat Ba 05 (31.25%) 10 (62.50%) 01 (06.25%) 16 (100%)
Table 4. The avian composition containing parasitic flatworms
according to each sex in three national parks and sexes in each park
Bird sex
Number and
percentage of sex
in three national parks
National park
Xuan Son Tam Dao Cat Ba
Male 26 (39.40%)
31 (46.97%) 19 (28.79%) 16 (24.24%) Female 29 (43.94%)
Juvenile 11 (16.66%)
Total 66 (100%)
In comparison with sex and populations of sixty-six avian individuals containing
parasitic flatworms, they decrease in the following order: 29 females (43.94% of the
A role of wild bird population in the transmission of parasitic flatworms (Platyhelminthes
105
total number) > 26 males (39.40%) > 11 juveniles (16.66%). Concerning the prevalence
of parasitic flatworm infections in birds, there is no clear sex difference between
females and males. Particularly in Tam Dao NP, analyzed sex ratio showed that the
percentage of avian individuals containing parasitic flatworms decrease in the following
order: male 52.63% of the total number of birds > female 31.58% > juvenile 15.79%.
It is recorded that the rate of flatworm containing in the juvenile avian population is
not high, only 16.66% of the total individuals obtained. Thus, along with biological age,
the rate of bird flatworm infection increases. Our investigation was done with avian
populations living in the lower shrubs close to the soil environment, and one of their
food sources being soil arthropods [10, 11, 19]. Likely, these are the main ways of
infection and transmission of parasitic flatworms in studied wild birds. This is also an
assessment given by Gray et al. (2010) and WHO (2020) [3, 4].
2.2.3. Species similarity of wild avian populations containing parasitic flatworms
Analysis of the distribution of bird populations containing flatworms according to
three national parks showed that they decreased in the following order: Xuan Son >
Tam Dao > Cat Ba. They were found 46.97% > 28.79% > 24.24% of a total of sixty-six
bird specimens, respectively (Tables 2-4). The figures show that there are clear
differences in the number of birds containing flatworms between the Xuan Son National
Park, in comparison with Tam Dao and Cat Ba National Parks, 31 vs. 19 and 16,
respectively.
Figure 1 showed that species composition similarities between the three studied
national parks are not high, ranging from 14.02% to 34.03%. The highest species
composition similarity was registered between Xuan Son National Park and Cat Ba
National Park, reaching 34.03%. The three common species between them are
Allophoixus pallidus, Macronous gularis, Cyornis bayumas (13.63% of total species
number).
Tam Dao National Park has a distinct difference in bird species composition
compared to the two above national parks. Particularly, species composition similarity
between Tam Dao National Park compared to Xuan Son and Cat Ba National Parks,
reaching only 16.01%. Specifically, only just three out of twenty-two avian species
identified, accounting for 13.63% of the total species number, are found common to
both Xuan Son and Tam Dao National Parks, namely Allophoixus pallidus, Pellorneum
tickelli and Alcippe morrisonia. Only the one avian species, Allophoixus pallidus,
accounting for 4.54% of the total species number, was found common to the Tam Dao
and Cat Ba National Parks. This is also the only species found in all three national parks
(Xuan Son, Tam Dao, and Cat Ba National Parks).
The data obtained on the highest bird species composition similarity between Xuan
Son National Park of northwest mountainous region and Cat Ba National Park of Hong
River Delta region, and their three common species containing flatworm, and one bird
species, namely Allophoixus pallidus, found in all three studied national parks, are very
significant from a parasitological point of view. These are important factors that should
be considered when assessing the potential for transmission and spread of parasitic
flatworms and pathogens through bird populations, bats, and possibly oribatid mites as well.
Georgiev B. Boyko, Mariaux Jean, Vasileva P. Gergana, Nguyen Quoc Huy and Vu Quang Manh
106
Figure 1. A cluster of species avian species similarities between three national parks
(species similarities in %)
3. Conclusions
In three national parks (Xuan Son, Tam Dao, and Cat Ba National Parks), 22 wild
avian species of 10 families were found to contain parasitic flatworms (Cestoidea and
Trematodea). According to the species number containing parasitic flatworms, the bird
families are ranking as Timaliidae recorded with 7 species > Leiothrichidae and
Nectariniidae both with 3 species > Pycononotidae and Muscicapidae both with 2
species > Vireonidae, Sylvidae, Picidae, Cisticolidae and Cettiidae with 1 species. By
sex, avian populations containing parasitic flatworms decrease by the order: females
accounting for 43.94% of the total individuals > males for 39,40% > juveniles for
16.66%.
Three bird species containing flatworms A. pallidus, M. gularis and C. bayumas
were found in two of the studied national parks, among them, only the first species was
found common to all three studied national parks. They are vectors of high significance
from a parasitological point of view.
Acknowledgements. The authors would like to thank Ph.D. Hoang Ngoc Hung (Hong
Duc University, Thanh Hoa province, Vietnam) for checking the scientific and
Vietnamese names of the birds. We also thank Ph.D. student Ha Tra My (CEBRED,
Hanoi National University of Education, Vietnam) for checking the data of the
multivariate ecological research version 6, Primer 6.
REFERENCES
[1] Krivolutsky D., Vu Quang Manh, Phan The Viet, 1997: The oribatid mites (Acarina:
Oribatei) of Vietnam, In “Tropical Medicine”, Vol. I. The Russian-Vietnamese Tropical
Centre, Nauka, Moscow-Hanoi, 130-145 (in Russian).
[2] Le Thi Xuan, Malinee Thairungroj Anantaphruti, Phan Anh Tuan, Le Xuan Tu, Tran Vinh
Hien, 2003. The first human infection with Bertiella studeri in Vietnam. The Southeast
Asian Journal of Tropical Medicine and Public Health, 34(2), pp. 298-300.
Group average
Tam Đảo
Xuân Sơn
Cát Bà
S
a
m
p
le
s
100806040200
Similarity
Transform: Square root
Resemblance: S17 Bray Curtis similarity
A role of wild bird population in the transmission of parasitic flatworms (Platyhelminthes
107
[3] Gray J, Zintl A, Hildebrandt A, Hunfeld KP, Weiss L., 2010. Zoonotic babesiosis: an
overview of the disease and novel aspects of pathogen identity. Ticks Tick Borne Dis. 1: 3-
10. doi: 10.1016/j.ttbdis.2009.11.003. Epub 2009 Dec 24.
[4] WHO, 2020. Soil-transmitted helminth infections, 2 March 2020. https://www.who.int/ news-
room/fact-sheets/detail/soil-transmitted-helminth-infections.
[5] Nguyen Quynh Huong, Nga NTT, Long NV, Luu BD, Latinne A, Pruvot M, Phuong NT,
Quang LTV, Hung VV, Lan NT, Hoa NT, Minh PQ, Diep NT, Tung N, Ky VD, Roberton
SI, Thuy HB, Long NV, Gilbert M, Wicker L, Olson SH, 2020. Coronavirus testing
indicates transmission risk increases along wildlife supply chains for human consumption
in Vietnam, 2013-2014. Plos one, Published: August 10, 2020, https://doi.org/10.1371/
journal.pone.0237129.
[6] Caira, J. N., K. Jensen, B. B. Georgiev, R. Kuchta, D. T. J. Littlewood, J. Mariaux, T.
Scholz, V. V. Tkach, and A. Waeschenbach, 2017. An overview of tapeworms from
vertebrate bowels of the earth. In Planetary Biodiversity Inventory (2008-2017):
Tapeworms from Vertebrate Bowels of the Earth. J. N. Caira and K. Jensen (eds.).
University of Kansas, Natural History Museum, Special Publication No. 25, Lawrence,
KS, USA no. 25: 1-20. https://nhm.openrepository.com/bitstream/ handle/10141/622379/
2017_PBICestoda_Chapt01_Overview.pdf?sequence=1.
[7] Vu Dinh Thong, 2007. Bat conservation at Cat Ba Biosphere Reserve, North-East
Vietnam, August 2006 - September 2007. Final CLP Project Report, 1-19.
[8] Vu Quang Mạnh, Nguyen Huy Tri, Nguyen Thị Hoa, 2014. Role of oribatid mites (Acari:
Oribatida) as a vector of transmission of tapeworm (Cestoda) in soil ecosystem of Cat Ba
National Park, Hai Phong city, Vietnam National University Journal of Natural Sciences
and Technology, Vol. 30, No 1S, Hanoi, 137-146 (in Vietnamese).
[9] Bird Life International in Indochina, 2004. Sourcebook of Existing and Proposed Protected
Areas in Vietnam. Second Edition. Hanoi, Vol. I.
[10] Vo Quy, Nguyen Cu, 1999. A list of Vietnam’s birds. Agricultural Publishing House,
Hanoi (in Vietnamese).
[11] Richard Crail & Le Quy Minh, 2018. Birds of VietNam, Lunx and BirdLife International
Field Guides, Lynx Edicions, Barcelona.
[12] Nguyen Thi Le, 1979. The fauna of Vietnam’s Cestoda - Parasites on Birds and Mammals.
DSc. Thesis. Academy of Sciences, Moscow, USSR (in Russian).
[13] Khalil, L F, A Jones, and R A Bray (Eds), 1994. Keys to the Cestode Parasite of
Vertebrates. Wallingford: CAB International, 1-768.
[14] Nguyen Thi Le, 1995. Trematodes (Trematoda) parasitizing on Vietnam’s birds and
animals, H., Science and Technology Publishing House, 1-250 (in Vietnamese).
[15] Clarke KR, Gorley R. N., 2001. Primer v5: user manual/tutorial. Primer-E Ltd. Plymouth.
[16] PRIMER 6 for Window 2007. Version 5.2.4.
[17] Grochovskaya Y, 1967. Insects and Mites - A vector of transmission of sickness for
humans in Vietnam. DSc. Thesis. 1-433 (in Russian).
[18] Ermilov, S.G., Anichkin, A.E. & Pal’ko, 2013. I.V. Oribatid mites (Acari) from nests of
some birds in South Vietnam. Entmol. Rev. 93, 799-804. https://doi.org/10.1134/
S0013873813060122.
[19] Vo Quy, 1971. Biology of common nesting birds in Vietnam Scientific Techniques
Publishing House. Hanoi. 1-283 (in Vietnamese).
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
a_role_of_wild_bird_population_in_the_transmission_of_parasi.pdf