Accurate and reliable forecasting of reservoir
inflow highly depends on the meteorological forecasting (rainfall, temperature, etc.). As a result of
using observed rainfall data, it somehow reduces
the kind of error caused by input data.
The analysis was carried out with (1) the parameters transferred from the neighbour catchment, and (2) the parameters auto-optimized continuously based on the SCE algorithm and realtime updating at predicted time indicated that the
latter method provides more reliable results than
the former one. It is possibly because the autocalibrated parameters based on real-time updating algorithm have a good reflection of the catchment states at predicted time – a region having
Figure 4. The observed and forecast discharged hydrograph using the parameter set 279
Journal of Ecological Engineering Vol. 19(3), 2018
completely no data of catchment attributes (land
humidity, land’s water storage capacity, etc.), the
forecast shows good agreement with the observed
flow. Using the proposed method for the inflow
simulation is advantageous, because it can provide credible forecast for the catchment without
any historical discharge data. Nevertheless, the
model parameters are capable of continually updating so that the forecasting at subsequent time
steps can be operated with high accuracy; hence,
the water level of the reservoir and observed rainfall need to be updated continuously. This raising
point can be done by the installation of automatic
gauges. For the 6-h, 12-h ahead forecast cases,
the forecast error is 10% and 20%, respectively.
Although the accuracy of the forecast rainfall decreases as the lead time increased, the results indicated that a real-time updating algorithm incorporated into optimized auto-calibration method of
the parameters of MIKE NAM model can enhance
the efficiency of inflow forecasting for a data
scarce region. Further research for more accurate
and efficient prediction is still required. However,
integrating the data assimilation algorithm into
the forecast process to bridge the gap between the
theory and practice can be a possible solution.
6 trang |
Chia sẻ: honghp95 | Lượt xem: 593 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem nội dung tài liệu An Approach for Flow Forecasting in Ungauged Catchments – A Case Study for Ho Ho reservoir catchment, Ngan Sau River, Central Vietnam, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
74
INTRODUCTION
Reservoir management can be viewed as an
important strategic perspective for the socio-
economic development of a region, related to
hydro-power development, water supply for irri-
gation, flood control etc. However, the variability
of hydro-meteorological forcing and economic
activities within the river basin are expected to
significantly impact its characteristic. In order to
maximize the performance of a single-reservoir
as well as multi-reservoir system, having accu-
rate reservoir inflow forecasting with enough lead
time poses a challenge to water managers.
The development of model methods has been
widely applied as an effective method for the res-
ervoir inflow forecasting [An et al. 2012, Anh et
al. 2015]. Coupled neural networks have recently
become a well-known tool for better forecasting of
the inflow hydrograph [Sanjeet et al. 2015, Krish-
na 2014]. However, in this model, a large amount
of hydrologic data is required to determine the
adaptive weights, which is usually unavailable in
data-scarce regions. Using the distributed models
may be inappropriate for real-time flow forecast-
ing since the simulation can be time-consuming
[Hapuarachchi et al. 2008]. A lumped model, there-
fore, is possibly the best choice for forecasting in
an ungauged catchment. With the selected model,
the accuracy of forecasting is prone to uncertainty
depending on the forecasting meteorological data,
forecasting scheme and the reliability of the used
model. The aim of this study is to enhance the
reliability of the model based on continuous op-
timization method to specify updated parameter
values for reservoir inflow forecasting. For that
purpose, model validation and calibration are key
steps in any forecast models and simulation study.
Journal of Ecological Engineering Received: 2018.02.04
Accepted: 2018.03.15
Published: 2018.05.01Volume 19, Issue 3, May 2018, pages 74–79
https://doi.org/10.12911/22998993/85759
An Approach for Flow Forecasting in Ungauged Catchments
– A Case Study for Ho Ho reservoir catchment, Ngan Sau River,
Central Vietnam
Dang Dinh Kha1*, Nguyen Y Nhu1, Tran Ngoc Anh1,2
1 Department of Hydrology and Water Resources, VNU University of Science, Vietnam National University,
Hanoi, 334 Nguyen Trai, Thanh Xuan, Hanoi, Vietnam
2 Center For Environmental Fluid Dynamics, VNU University of Science, Vietnam National University, Hanoi,
334 Nguyen Trai, Thanh Xuan, Hanoi, Vietnam
* Corresponding author’s e-mail: dangdinhkha@hus.edu.vn
ABSTRACT
Reservoir inflow forecasting with high reliability plays an important role in the operation and management
of the reservoir for power generation, irrigation, flood prevention as well as ensuring the safety of the dam.
However, the level of forecast accuracy is limited, since its performance depends on rainfall forecasting and hy-
drological model. In order to increase the efficiency of forecasting, this study introduces the inflow forecasting
method that integrates the real-time updating techniques with continuous optimization method of MIKE NAM
model to specify the appropriate parameter set for forecasting time. The proposed forecasting method was tested
for the Ho Ho reservoir, the area facing the scarcity of historical data for model calibration and verification. The
analysis of the forecasting results for Ho Ho reservoir using transferred parameters from the stable calibrated
parameter values at Hoa Duyet station (downstream of Ho Ho reservoir) and the results obtained using the
adapted parameters by the proposed method shows that the adapted parameter values provides a more reliable
forecast, which will better serve the decision making.
Keywords: real time updating, flood, forecasting, ungauged catchment.
75
Journal of Ecological Engineering Vol. 19(3), 2018
However, it should be noted that there is a limited
number of river basins with long enough observed
discharge data to capture the coverage of the hy-
drological event within the basin to both calibrate
and validate the model, especially for the area
with construction of new reservoir. Several studies
“transfer” the parameter values of the model being
specified for one catchment to the predicted catch-
ment having similar characteristics [An et al. 2013,
Bardossy 2007]. However, this procedure assumes
that only one set of parameters is obtained, which
possibly lead to a good model performance only
for the events with similar conditions. In fact, due
to the large complexity of the corresponding natu-
ral phenomena in Vietnam as result of its tropical
monsoon climate and its time variation, the model
parameters need to be transferred for the predicted
catchment and the weather conditions under study.
Further, the socio-economic activities within the
basin have an influence on the hydrological re-
gime coupled with the impact of climate change
which leads to an increase in the complexity of
hydrological processes in a catchment. Conse-
quently, the identification of a unique dataset
providing a good model performance for any
weather conditions is practically impossible. In
such a case, a flow forecasting system incorporat-
ing a real-time updating algorithm that adapts the
model and catchment state can improve the fore-
casting accuracy. On that basis, this study tested
and discussed the inflow forecasting method that
integrates the real-time updating techniques in-
cluding three categories: updating (1) input vari-
ables; (2) model parameters; and (3) output vari-
ables and the continuous optimization method of
MIKE NAM model to specify parameters on the
basis of reservoir water balance equation for the
Ho Ho reservoir inflow forecasting.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study area and dataset used
The Ho Ho reservoir is constructed on the
Ngan Sau River, a main tributary of La River
located in Ha Tinh province, central Viet Nam.
The area of Ho Ho reservoir catchment is 278.6
km2 with the storage capacity of the reservoir
being 38 million m3. The Ho Ho reservoir offi-
cially operates from the beginning of 2013.
From 2017, three automatic rain gauges and
an automatic water level recorder were installed
upstream of the Ho Ho reservoir, these recorded
data can be automatically updated for the data-
base of reservoir management office.
In addition, the observed daily rainfall for 7
years from Jan 01, 2010 to Dec 31, 2016 were
collected from the National Hydro-Meteoro-
logical Service, Vietnam for three stations Chu
Figure 1. Rain gauge network in the study area
Journal of Ecological Engineering Vol. 19(3), 2018
76
Le, Huong Khe and Hoa Duyet in the study area
(Figure 1). The daily water level and discharge
with the same period were collected from Hoa
Duyet station with the catchment area of 1880
km2, located downstream of the Ho Ho reservoir
(71 km from the site). These data are employed
for calibration and validation of the model to
serve the reservoir inflow forecasting.
Methodology
MIKE NAM, a lumped model, developed at
DHI Water & Environment has been widely used
in researches [Keskin et al. 2007, Liu et al. 2007,
Kamel et al. 2008]. The model simulates the water
movement in the land phase of the hydrological
cycle by continuously accounting for the water
content in four different and mutually interrelated
storages, including snow storage, surface storage,
lower or root zone storage and groundwater stor-
age [DHI 2004]. The parameters of MIKE NAM
model can be identified by either the manual trial-
and-error method or automatic optimization meth-
od. The auto-calibration is done to optimize two
objective functions: (a) minimizing the water bal-
ance error (%WBL) (b) minimizing the root mean
square error (RMSE) [DHI 2004]. The auto-cali-
brated method provides the good performance in
simulating each hydrological event, but with vari-
ous hydrological events, they require different pa-
rameter sets to obtain good performance [Giang et
al. 2010]. In recent years, MIKE NAM model has
been considered as an efficient tool for forecasting
and water resources assessment in Vietnam [An
et al. 2013, Long et al. 2010, Giang et al. 2010].
However, most of the study focused on simulating
the historical events with a single parameter set. In
this paper, a different approach of integrating the
real-time updating technique with optimization al-
gorithm SCE (Shuffled Complex Evolution) with
the RMSE objective function in MIKE NAM for
parameter auto-calibration is applied. The cali-
brated parameters will be linked and updated auto-
matically into the runoff model to forecast the in-
flow for the next time step. The rainfall and water
level data from automatic recorder will be updated
as input variables for parameters updating. The
automatic water level recorders at the reservoir are
used to estimate the reservoir inflow according to
the reservoir water balance equation (1):
(1)
where: Q(t) – reservoir inflow [m3/s],
qr(t) – reservoir outflow [m3/s],
dV/dt – varying of storage capacity of the
reservoir in time [m3/s].
Simplified, the trial-and-error method will be
used to solve the equation (1) which is based on the
characteristics of reservoir, including water level
– storage capacity relationships Z ~ V, water level
– structure outflow (turbine, spillway) Z~ q, and
water level – surface area Z~ F. These relationships
were developed based on the reservoir survey data.
The daily rainfall data collected from three
stations Chu Le, Huong Khe and Hoa Duyet in the
study area will be used to estimate the basin aver-
age rainfall with the Thiessen Polygon method.
The model calibration and validation will be done
by combining the trial-and-error with automatic
optimization method to obtain the best result.
The accuracy of simulation assessed by using the
Nash-Sutcliffe coefficient, which were of 0.7 and
0.76 being obtained with the period of 2010-2013
and 2014-2016, respectively, for calibration and
verification (Figure 2). This indicates that the ob-
tained parameters were reasonably good for fore-
casting purpose at Hoa Duyet station.
In order to forecast the Ho Ho reservoir inflow,
these parameters need to be transferred from Hoa
Duyet to Ho Ho using regression relationships be-
tween the catchment area defined by Ho Ho reser-
voir (278.6 km2) and the one by Hoa Duyet station
(1880 km2), referred to as parameter set 1. The pa-
rameters of time constant for routing overland flow
(CK1, 2) and baseflow (BF) will be revised since
they present high sensitivity to the catchment size.
Besides, the study integrates the real-time
water level, rainfall updating algorithm and auto-
calibrated method in MIKE NAM to optimize the
parameter values. The algorithm was developed
in the Matlab environment to auto-update the
observed data from recorder, auto-calibrate and
forecast the Ho Ho reservoir inflow via MIKE
NAM model. In turn, when the water level and
rainfall at the reservoir are updated at time t, the
model will auto-forecast the reservoir inflow at
t + Δt, the parameters of MIKE NAM model at
subsequent time step, (t + 2Δt), can be obtained
according to updating measured flow, water level
and rainfall data at t + Δt. The updating observed
input variables at t + Δt and the re-update param-
eters for time t + 2Δt (parameter set 2) will be
used to forecast the inflow at t + 2Δt. It means that
the parameter set 2 will be updated continuously
to correctly reflect the catchment attributes at the
predicted time.
77
Journal of Ecological Engineering Vol. 19(3), 2018
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The hourly rainfall data of flood event from
July 15, 2017 to July 17, 2017 were collected for
forecast testing and the results are presented in
Figures 3 and 4.
The Figure 3 indicates the forecasting result
using the parameter set 1; it can be seen that un-
der no rain conditions, water is kept in soil and
water bodies on catchment to maintain the river,
the model shows a good performance. However,
under heavy-rainfall conditions, the result sug-
gests that the model overestimated the simulat-
ed discharge, the error of flood peak flows was
around 80%. This indicates that reasonably good
model parameters obtained during the calibration
and validation at Hoa Duyet station, are not com-
parable for the forecast of the Ho Ho reservoir
inflow. This is possibly because the parameter set
1 does not correctly reflect the attributes of catch-
ment at the predicted time (soil humidity, land’s
water storage capacity etc).
The Figure 4 shows the observed and forecast
discharge using the parameter set 2 for different
Figure 2. The observed and simulated discharge at Hoa Duyet station
Figure 3. The observed and forecast discharge using the parameter set 1
Journal of Ecological Engineering Vol. 19(3), 2018
78
time steps. Similarly, under no rain conditions
(from July 15, 2017 at 1:00:00 PM to July 16,
2017 at 1:00:00 PM) the model shows good per-
formance as a result of stable inflow. At the initial
time t when rain occurs (July 16, 2017 at 4:00:00
PM) the model performed relatively worse with
the forecast error of 45% for the 12 hours ahead
forecast cases. The possible reason of this result
is to employ the parameters optimized from the
previous time step (the no rain parameter set) for
the forecast cases. In order to make prediction at
t + 1 (July 16, 2017 at 7:00:00 PM), the model
is updated with observed water level at t of the
Ho Ho reservoir which means that this optimized
parameters somehow better reflect the attributes
of catchment. As a result, forecast values are
improved significantly; the errors are 10% and
20% with the lead time of 6 hours and 12 hours,
respectively. The error of peak discharge for
a 3-h prediction is around 20%. For the subse-
quent time steps (t + 2, t + 3,...) the forecast dis-
charge hydrograph approaches ever closer to the
observed discharge hydrograph. Even though the
accuracy of inflow forecasting decreases when the
lead time is increased because the forecast error
is accumulated from the previous lead-time fore-
casting; these results indicate that the proposed
inflow forecasting method can increase the cred-
ibility of forecast information in comparison with
the forecast information using the transferred pa-
rameter values from another catchment.
CONCLUSION
Accurate and reliable forecasting of reservoir
inflow highly depends on the meteorological fore-
casting (rainfall, temperature, etc.). As a result of
using observed rainfall data, it somehow reduces
the kind of error caused by input data.
The analysis was carried out with (1) the pa-
rameters transferred from the neighbour catch-
ment, and (2) the parameters auto-optimized con-
tinuously based on the SCE algorithm and real-
time updating at predicted time indicated that the
latter method provides more reliable results than
the former one. It is possibly because the auto-
calibrated parameters based on real-time updat-
ing algorithm have a good reflection of the catch-
ment states at predicted time – a region having
Figure 4. The observed and forecast discharged hydrograph using the parameter set 2
79
Journal of Ecological Engineering Vol. 19(3), 2018
completely no data of catchment attributes (land
humidity, land’s water storage capacity, etc.), the
forecast shows good agreement with the observed
flow. Using the proposed method for the inflow
simulation is advantageous, because it can pro-
vide credible forecast for the catchment without
any historical discharge data. Nevertheless, the
model parameters are capable of continually up-
dating so that the forecasting at subsequent time
steps can be operated with high accuracy; hence,
the water level of the reservoir and observed rain-
fall need to be updated continuously. This raising
point can be done by the installation of automatic
gauges. For the 6-h, 12-h ahead forecast cases,
the forecast error is 10% and 20%, respectively.
Although the accuracy of the forecast rainfall de-
creases as the lead time increased, the results in-
dicated that a real-time updating algorithm incor-
porated into optimized auto-calibration method of
the parameters of MIKE NAM model can enhance
the efficiency of inflow forecasting for a data
scarce region. Further research for more accurate
and efficient prediction is still required. However,
integrating the data assimilation algorithm into
the forecast process to bridge the gap between the
theory and practice can be a possible solution.
Acknowledgements
This research is funded by the VNU Univer-
sity of Science under project number TN.17.16.
The author is PhD/Doctoral Student under the
911 Program of VNU University of Science, Viet-
nam National University.
REFERENCES
1. An N.L., Ngoc N.T.B. 2012. Research on flood
forecasting for reservoir in the Ba river. Journal of
Water Resources & Environmental Engineering,
No 38 (in Vietnamese).
2. An N.L., Hoa N.N. 2013. Research on flood fore-
casting in Vu Gia – Thu Bon River Basin. Journal
of Water Resources & Environmental Engineering,
No 43 (in Vietnamese).
3. Anh L.T., Son N.T. 2015. Some experiences for ap-
plying Hydrological, Hydraulic models to Hydro-
logic Forecasting, Journal of Science VNU. Natural
Sciences and Technology, 31(1S) (in Vietnamese)
4. Bardossy A. 2007. Calibration of hydrological
model parameters for ungagged catchments. Hy-
drol. Earth Syst, Scie., 11, 703-710.
5. DHI Water & Environment. 2004. MIKE 11 Refer-
ence Manual.
6. Giang N.T. Phuong T.A. 2010. Calibration and
verification of a hydrological model using event
data, VNU Journal of Science, Earth Science, 26.
(in Vietnamese).
7. Hapuarachchi H.A.P., Wang Q.J.A. 2008. Review
of Methods and Systems Available for Flash Flood
Forecasting; Report for the Bureau of Meteorol-
ogy, Australia; Commonwealth Scientific and In-
dustrial Research Organization (CSIRO): Dick-
son, Australia.
8. Kamel A.H. 2008. Application of a hydrodynamic
MIKE 11 model for the Euphrates River in Iraq.
Slovak Journal of Civil Engineering, 2, 1-7.
9. Keskin F., Sensoy A.A., Sorman A. 2007. Applica-
tion of MIKE11 Model for the Simulation of Snow-
melt Runoff in Yuvacik Dam Basin, Turkey. Interna-
tional Congress on River Basin Management, The
role of general directorate of state Hydraulic works
(DSI) in development of water resources of Turkey.
10. Krishna B. 2014. Comparison of wavelet based
ANN and regression models for reservoir inflow
forecasting. J Hydrol Eng, 19(7), 1385-1400.
11. Liu H.L., Chen X., Bao A.M., Ling Wang. 2007.
Investigation of groundwater response to overland
flow and topography using a coupled MIKE SHE/
MIKE 11 modeling system for an arid watershed.
Journal of Hydrology, 347, 448-459.
12. Long V.D., Anh T.N., Binh H.T., Kha D.D. 2010.
An introduction to flood forecast technology in
Ben Hai and Thach Han river systems using MIKE
11 model. Vietnam National University Journal of
Science, 26(3S), 397-404.
13. Sanjeet K., Mukesh K.T., Chandranath C., Ashok
M. 2015. Reservoir Inflow Forecasting Using En-
semble Models Based on Neural Networks, Wave-
let Analysis and Bootstrap Method. Water Resour
Manage, 29, 4863-4883, doi: 10.1007/s11269-
015-1095-7.
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
- an_approach_for_flow_1805_2062752.pdf