Characteristics of concomitant cardiovascular diseases in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
The proportion of patients with arrhythmia
decreased with the severity of the disease,
in stage II the proportion of patients with
arrhythmia was 45.3%. In stage III, it was
43.4% and in stage IV it was 11.3%.
However, the difference was not statistically
significant with p > 0.05. The results were
the same for patients with hypertension
(p > 0.05).
The proportion of patients with COPD
with the right atrial thickness on ECG,
systolic pulmonary hypertension, heart
failure and ischemic heart disease were
the highest in stage III. Stage IV had the
lowest proportion. However, the difference
was statistically significant only in patients
with the right atrial thickness on ECG with
p < 0.05 and heart failure with p < 0.01.
This is explanable because most
cardiovascular disease is associated with
COPD, rather than as a consequence
of the disease. Particularly, chronic cor
pulmonale as a consequence of the
disease on the right heart, there were
stages but the incidence did not increase
gradually with the stage of the disease as
many authors have commented [1, 8],
that it was highest in stage III (53.6%) and
the lowest in stage IV (11.6%), because
patients in stage IV were treated primarily
at the intensive care unit, therefore in our
study the number of patients in stage IV
was small, so it was difficult to exactly
assess the rate of chronic cor pulmonale.
The proportion of patients with COPD
with a peripheral vascular disease was
the highest in stage III (75%) and none of
the patients in stage IV had peripheral
vascular disease. The difference was not
statistically significant with p > 0.05.
7 trang |
Chia sẻ: hachi492 | Lượt xem: 9 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem nội dung tài liệu Characteristics of concomitant cardiovascular diseases in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
181
CHARACTERISTICS OF CONCOMITANT CARDIOVASCULAR
DISEASES IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE
PULMONARY DISEASE
Bui Mai Huong1; Nguyen Dinh Tien2
SUMMARY
Objectives: To examine the characteristics of concomitant cardiovascular diseases in
patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Subjects and methods: A cross-sectional
descriptive study was conducted on 162 patients who had a confirmed diagnosis of chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease from January 2016 to October 2018. Results and conclusions:
The average age of our study patient group was 72.3 ± 9.8. The majority of patients was
> 60 years old, accounting for 89.4%. The male/female ratio was 3/1. The rate of cardiovascular
diseases: valvular heart disease encountered in 100% of patients with chronic obstructive
pulmonary disease, hypertension accounted for 84%, arrhythmia accounted for 65.4%, the
proportion of patients with ischemic heart disease and right heart failure syndrome was 57.49%
and 36.4%. Only 2.5% of the patients had peripheral vascular disease. Characteristics of heart
failure: the proportion of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease with heart failure
accounted for 50.6%: right heart failure accounted for 36.4%, left heart failure accounted for
0.6% and two-side heart failure accounted for 13.9%. The relationship between cardiovascular
disease characteristics and the stages of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: the patients
with stage III chronic obstructive pulmonary disease had the highest rate of chronic cor pulmonale,
heart failure, ischemic heart disease (48.6%; 53.6%; 52.9%; 46.2% and 75.0%).
* Keywords: Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; Cardiovascular disease.
INTRODUCTION
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
(COPD) is one of the leading causes of
morbidity and mortality worldwide resulting
in increasing serious economic and social
burden. Although COPD affects mainly
the lungs, it also causes many systemic
diseases, especially cardiovascular diseases:
the disease not only damages the right
heart, but also the left heart, arrhythmias,
myocardial ischemia, atherosclerosis,
embolism, etc. The incidence of COPD is
often directly related to smoking rate
although in many countries, air pollution
outdoors, at work and indoors are the
main risk factors for COPD. Smoking is
also a risk factor for cardiovascular disease.
Therefore, in patients with COPD, there
are many accompanying other cardiovascular
diseases and clinical manifestations
of COPD are enriched. The effects of
cardiovascular disease caused by COPD
and .the .combination of cardiovascular
1. Saint Paul Hospital
2. 108 Military Central Hospital
Corresponding author: Bui Mai Huong (huongkorea07@gmail.com)
Date received: 21/12/2019
Date accepted: 15/01/2020
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
182
diseases with COPD exacerbate the severity
of the disease, increase complications
and increase mortality rate. We conducted
this study: To analyse the characteristics
of concomitant cardiovascular diseases in
patients with COPD
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
1. Subjects.
162 patients with COPD were treated
at the Department of Internal Medicine -
Pulmonary Division, Department of
Internal Medicine - Cardiology and the
Department of Internal Medicine,
Emergency Resuscitation - Saint Paul
Hospital. The study duration was from
January 2016 to October 2018.
* Selection criteria:
- Patients with a confirmed diagnosis
of COPD according to GOLD (2016).
- Patients with a confirmed diagnosis
of the Hypertension Clinical Practice
Guidelines (2017) and JNC 7.
- Patients with a confirmed diagnosis
of the ESC Guidelines (2016).
- Patients with a confirmed diagnosis
of chronic cor-pulmonale an expert
committee of the Word Health Organization
(1998).
- Patients agreed to participate in
the study.
* Exclusion criteria:
- Patients who were impossible to
measure pulmonary ventilation function
and did not take an electrocardiogram
(ECG), echocardiography.
- Patients did not agree to cooperate.
- Patients who were re-hospitalized
during the study.
2. Methods.
A cross-sectional descriptive study.
* Information needed to collect:
- General information: Age, gender,
occupation, living region, reasons for
admission to the hospital.
- History, medical history.
- Clinical examination.
- Classification of disease stage according
to GOLD (2016).
- Laboratory testing:
+ Measurement of pulmonary function
was done at the Pulmonary Department,
Saint Paul Hospital.
+ Echocardiography and pulse
measurements were made in the
echocardiography room - Saint Paul Hospital.
Clinical and paraclinical results were
compared with echocardiography.
+ Electrocardiography was made in the
Department of Internal Medicine - Pulmonary
Division, Department of Internal Medicine -
Cardiology, Saint Paul Hospital. Clinical
and paraclinical results were compared
with electrocardiography.
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
183
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
1. Age and gender characteristics.
Table 1: Distribution of the study patients by age and gender.
The study results showed that the average age of patients in the study was 72.3 ± 9.8.
The average age of our patients was higher than that of some domestic authors such
as Nguyen Chinh Dien (68.1 ± 9.3) [1]; Nguyen Thi Kim Oanh (67.06 ± 10.3) [2] and
also higher than some foreign authors such as Abroug et al [6]; Mailsel A.S (64 ± 17) [7].
The age of male patients was mainly in the age of 60 - 69 years and 70 - 79 years
old (47.6%). Meanwhile, the age of female patients was the most common in the age of
70 - 79 (9.9%) and there were no female patients aged < 50.
2. Rate of cardiovascular diseases in the study patients.
Table 2: Rate of types of cardiovascular disease in patients with COPD.
Types of cardiovascular disease n Rate (%)
Arrhythmia 106 65.4
Right atrial hypertrophy on ECG 74 45.7
Right heart failure syndrome 59 36.4 Chronic cor pulmonale
Systolic pulmonary hypertension 69 42.6
Valvular heart disease 162 100.0
Hypertension 136 84.0
Heart failure 82 50.6
Ischemic heart disease 93 57.4
Peripheral vascular disease 4 2.5
Common Male Female
Age group
n Rate (%) n Rate (%) n Rate (%)
p
< 50 1 0.6 1 0.8 0 0.0
50 - 59 16 9.9 13 10.7 3 7.3
60 - 69 49 30.2 39 24.1 10 6.2
70 - 79 54 33.3 38 23.5 16 9.9
≥ 80 42 25.9 30 18.5 12 7.4
> 0.05
Average age 72.3 ± 9.8 71.7 ± 9.9 74.3 ± 9.2
n 162 121 41
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
184
In cardiovascular diseases, valvular
heart disease in the elderly encountered
in 100% of patients with COPD.
Among cardiovascular diseases,
valvular heart disease in the elderly was
the most common in 100% of patients
with COPD.
The rate of hypertension in our study
was higher than that in Nguyen Thi
Kim Oanh’s findings with 37/100 patients
(37%) [2], because atherosclerosis and
overweight are now common causes and
more and more increasing. The rate of
arrhythmia in our study was lower than in
Nguyen Thi Kim Oanh’s with 76/100
patients (76%) [2] and the study results by
the General Cardiology Department of
Nhan Dan Gia Dinh Hospital (n = 96):
arrhythmia 70.8% [3].
The proportion of patients with chronic
cor pulmonale in our study by assessing
pulmonary hypertension through
echocardiography was lower than in
Ngo Quy Chau’s and Nguyen Chinh Dien’s
findings (70.6%) [1], Chu Thi Hanh
and Nguyen Thi Kim Oanh (75%) [2].
This relatively high proportion can be
explained by the fact that currently,
echocardiography can detect early
systolic pulmonary hypertension, helping
to diagnose early chronic cor pulmonale
while there is no clinical manifestation.
Another reason is that patients with
COPD in the above authors’ findings were
all in the Respiratory Center, Bachmai
Hospital which is at the central level,
so these patients at admission were often
severe and very severe, thus the rate
of right heart failure of these patients
was more frequent than in our study.
The proportion of patients with chronic
cor pulmonale diagnosed with right
atrial thickness manifestations on
electrocardiogram was 45.7%, our results
were similar to Nguyen Thi Thuy Nga’s
findings (35.8%) [4]; with 36.4% of the
patients suffering from right heart failure
syndrome. Our result was higher than
Nguyen Thi Kim Oanh’s (19%) [2].
The rate of heart failure in our study
was similar to that in Ngo Quy Chau’s and
Nguyen Chinh Dien’s (40.1%) [1], higher
than the study results by Nguyen Thi Kim
Oanh (22%) [2] and Nhan Dan Gia Dinh
Hospital (18.8%) [3].
The incidence of ischemic heart disease
in our study was higher than that in
Nguyen Thi Kim Oanh’s (12%) [2].
In this study, we found that 100% of
the study patients had concomitant
cardiovascular diseases, which was also
noted in some other studies on COPD.
Table 3: Characteristics of heart failure in patients with COPD.
Manifestation n Rate (%)
Right heart failure 59 36.4
Left heart failure (EF < 50%) 1 0.6 Heart failure
Total heart failure 22 13.6
Without heart failure 80 49.4
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
185
Thus, heart failure in our study was both a consequence of right heart failure of
COPD and a combination of left heart failure and COPD. Previous studies had shown
that about 10% of patients hospitalized for heart failure with COPD, recent reports
showed that this proportion increased to about 20 - 30% and also about 30% of
patients with COPD accompanied by left ventricular function failure. In the study by
Nguyen Chinh Dien, there were 41/102 patients with heart failure (40.1%) [1] and in the
study by Hoang Duc Bach there were 26/81 patients (32.1%) with heart failure (with a
BNP concentration > 100 pg/mL) [5].
3. Relationship between cardiovascular disease and clinical characteristics
in COPD.
Table 4: Relationship between cardiovascular disease in coronary artery disease
and the stages of COPD.
Stages of disease
II III IV Cardiovascular disease
n
Rate
(%) n
Rate
(%) n
Rate
(%)
p
Arrhythmia (n = 106) 48 45.3 46 43.4 12 11.3 > 0.05
Right atrial thickness on
ECG (n = 74) 29 39.2 36 48.6 9 12.2 < 0.05 Chronic cor
pulmonale Systolic pulmonary
hypertension (n = 69) 24 34.8 37 53.6 8 11.6 > 0.05
Valvular heart disease (n = 162) 80 49.4 67 41.4 15 9.3 > 0.05
Hypertension (n = 136) 69 50.7 54 39.7 13 9.6 > 0.05
Heart failure (n = 82) 30 36.6 43 52.9 9 11 < 0.01
Ischemic heart disease (n = 93) 41 44.1 43 46.2 9 9.7 > 0.05
Peripheral vascular disease (n = 4) 1 25.0 3 75.0 0 0 > 0.05
The proportion of patients with arrhythmia
decreased with the severity of the disease,
in stage II the proportion of patients with
arrhythmia was 45.3%. In stage III, it was
43.4% and in stage IV it was 11.3%.
However, the difference was not statistically
significant with p > 0.05. The results were
the same for patients with hypertension
(p > 0.05).
The proportion of patients with COPD
with the right atrial thickness on ECG,
systolic pulmonary hypertension, heart
failure and ischemic heart disease were
the highest in stage III. Stage IV had the
lowest proportion. However, the difference
was statistically significant only in patients
with the right atrial thickness on ECG with
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
186
p < 0.05 and heart failure with p < 0.01.
This is explanable because most
cardiovascular disease is associated with
COPD, rather than as a consequence
of the disease. Particularly, chronic cor
pulmonale as a consequence of the
disease on the right heart, there were
stages but the incidence did not increase
gradually with the stage of the disease as
many authors have commented [1, 8],
that it was highest in stage III (53.6%) and
the lowest in stage IV (11.6%), because
patients in stage IV were treated primarily
at the intensive care unit, therefore in our
study the number of patients in stage IV
was small, so it was difficult to exactly
assess the rate of chronic cor pulmonale.
The proportion of patients with COPD
with a peripheral vascular disease was
the highest in stage III (75%) and none of
the patients in stage IV had peripheral
vascular disease. The difference was not
statistically significant with p > 0.05.
CONCLUSIONS
The average age of our study patients
group was 72.3 ± 9.8. The majority of
patients was > 60 years old, accounting
for 89.4%, this is also the age at risk of
COPD and concomitant cardiovascular
disease. The male/female ratio was 3/1.
In cardiovascular diseases, valvular
heart disease in the elderly encountered
100% of patients with COPD. Hypertension
accounted for 84%. Patients with COPD
with arrhythmia accounted for 65.4%.
The proportion of patients with ischemic
heart disease and right heart failure
syndrome was 57.49% and 36.4%. Only
2.5% of patients had peripheral vascular
disease. The proportion of patients with
COPD with heart failure accounted for
50.6%, of which right heart failure
accounted for 36.4%, left heart failure
accounted for 0.6% and whole heart
failure accounted for 13.9%. The patients
with stage III COPD had the highest rate
of chronic cor pulmonale, heart failure,
ischemic heart disease (48.6%; 53.6%;
52.9%; 46.2% and 75%).
REFERENCES
1. Ngo Quy Chau, Nguyen Chinh Dien.
Research on some concomitant cardiovascular
diseases in patients with acute obstructive
pulmonary disease treated at the Respiratory
Center, Bach Mai Hospital. Specialty II Thesis.
Hanoi Medical University. 2010.
2. Nguyen Thi Kim Oanh. Research on
some cardiovascular diseases in patients with
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease treated
at the Respiratory Center, Bach Mai Hospital.
Master Thesis. 2013.
3. Survey on the rate of types of
concomitant cardiovascular diseases in patients
with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease at
the General Cardiology Department of Nhan
Dan Gia Dinh Hospital from February 2010 to
August 2011.
4. Nguyen Thi Thuy Nga. Research on
changes in morphology and right ventricular
diastolic function by Doppler echocardiography in
patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
187
disease and bronchial asthma. Military Medical
University. 2007.
5. Hoang Duc Bach. Clinical and paraclinical
characteristics and BNP concentration in
patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease treated at the Respiratory Department,
Bach Mai Hospital. Master of Medicine Thesis.
Hanoi Medical University. 2008.
6. Abroug F, Ounes B.L, Ncini N.
Association of left heart dysfunction with
severe exacerbation of chronic obstructive
pulmonary disease. Am J Respir Crit Care
Med. 2006, Vol 174, pp.990-996.
7. Maisel A.S. B-type natriuretic peptide
levels: A potential novel “White count” for
congestive heart failure. Journal of Cardiac
Failure. 2001, 7 (2), pp.183-193
8. Corinaldesi A, Zompatory M, Sturani C
et al. The assessment of pulmonary artery
pressure by pulsed in patients with obtructive
pneumopathy. Radiol Med (Torino). 1991, 8 (5),
pp.589-595.
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
characteristics_of_concomitant_cardiovascular_diseases_in_pa.pdf