The role of 64-Slides computed tomography scan in preoperative diagnosis of retroperitoneal laparoscopic surgery for patients with ureteropelvic junction obstruction at Viet Duc hospital
The image resolution density of CT is
much higher than conventional X-rays,
moreover, the enhanced contrast can cross
patients' areas of infection. In addition,
the urinary tract could also be clear
displayed in CT images. Results by
Kawamoto et al showed that CT not only
displayed obstruction ureter, but also the
location and the root of obstruction [7].
El-Nahas et al also reported similar results
that the obstruction of the ureteropelvic
that cannot be showed in the X-ray of
intravenous urinary system, could be seen
in CT-scanner in a group of 42 patients
with UJPO [8]. In study by Chong Xie
et al, the proportion of the visible of the
obstruction on CT-scan images was 90.2%,
much higher than the X-rays technique
(39.3%). Except for patients with completely
obstructed, CT-scanner may show most
of the urinary tract and the obstruction of
renal pelvis [9]. For patients with tumors
or kidney stones, CT-scanner could not
only show the urinary tract and fill the
defect of the tumor, but also reflected
the position and overall morphological
characteristics of the tumor, as well as the
condition of surrounding tissue. Consequently,
indirect diagnostic guesses can be avoided
by using CT-scanner and removed the
limitations in the X-ray urinary tract systems.
A further advantage of CT-scanner in the
diagnosis of UJPO is that the integrity,
morphology and perfusion of renal
parenchyma can be assessed in addition
to obtaining information about the spatial
orientation and presence of the disease.
Many studies had suggested that
CT-scanner should be considered as a
routine imaging technique in the diagnosis
and treatment of renal pelvic junction
obstruction [8]. The sensitivity of CT-scanner
in detecting the root cause of the obstruction
was determined to be 100%, much higher
than X-ray (74%) in group of patients with
chronic obstructive urological disease [10].
In our study, comparing the evaluation of
CT with the assessment during surgery,
the sensitivity and specificity of 64-slides
CT-scanner were above 85%, showing a
high value in pre-surgical diagnosis among
patients with UJPO. In the assessment of
renal pelvis diameter, the agreement
between CT-scanner imaging and the
macroscopic and microscopic anatomy
during surgery was nearly 90%, and the
sensitivity and specificity were high at 97.2%
and 96.2%, respectively. The agreement
rate in identifying abnormality of renal
artery was also high at 91.94%, the
Kappa’s score was 0.8079 (p < 0.001).
The angle of renal pelvis and ureter
and the position of ureters coming from
renal pelvis were also found at high level
of sensitivity and specificity (> 85%).
The pre-operations play an important role
in selecting surgical methods and shortening
surgery time. Our results showed that
64-slides CT-scanner could be diagnosed
with the high accurate rate in comparison
with the in-surgery assessment. We suggested
CT-scanner should be considered as gold
standard for diagnosing and pre-surgery
assessing among patients with UJPO.
6 trang |
Chia sẻ: hachi492 | Lượt xem: 4 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem nội dung tài liệu The role of 64-Slides computed tomography scan in preoperative diagnosis of retroperitoneal laparoscopic surgery for patients with ureteropelvic junction obstruction at Viet Duc hospital, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
212
THE ROLE OF 64-SLIDES COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY SCAN IN
PREOPERATIVE DIAGNOSIS OF RETROPERITONEAL
LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY FOR PATIENTS WITH
URETEROPELVIC JUNCTION OBSTRUCTION AT
VIET DUC HOSPITAL
Nguyen Duc Minh1; Hoang Long1; Vu Nguyen Khai Ca1
SUMMARY
Objectives: To determine the sensitivity and specificity of multidisciplinary computed
tomography in the diagnosis of ureteropelvic junction obstruction among patients undergoing
retroperitoneal laparoscopic surgery at Viet Duc Hospital from 2012 to 2017. Subjects and
methods: A prospective descriptive study on 62 patients diagnosed with ureteropelvic junction
obstruction at Viet Duc Hospital. Cohen's Kappa coefficient was used to evaluate the agreement
between CT-scanner and in-surgery assessment. Sensitivity and specificity were also calculated
to determine the reliability of 64-slides CT-scanner in diagnosing of damage of urinary system
among patients with ureteropelvic junction obstruction. Results: Comparison between 64-slides
CT-scanner imaging and evaluation anatomy during surgery, we found a high agreement of
renal pelvis diameter between 64-slides CT-scanner imaging and in-surgery assessment
(96.78%) and Cohen Kappa’s score was 0.9338 (p < 0.001). The sensitivity and specificity were
97.2% and 96.2%, respectively. The agreement in diagnosing abnormality of renal artery was
also high (91.94%) and Cohen Kappa’s score was 0.8079 (p < 0.001). The sensitivity and
specificity were found at 80% and 97.62%, respectively. CT-scanner was also found to have
high sensitivity and specificity in diagnosing the position of ureters coming from renal pelvis and
angle of renal pelvis and ureter (> 80%). Conclusions: The 64-slides CT-scanner showed high
sensitivity and specificity in diagnosing the damage of urinary system among patients with
ureteropelvic junction obstruction who underwent retroperitoneal laparoscopic surgery at
Viet Duc Hospital from 2012 to 2017.
* Keywords: Ureteropelvic junction obstruction; CT-scanner; Sensitivity; Specificity.
INTRODUCTION
Computed tomography (CT) imaging
procedure, especially 64-slides CT-scans
plays an important role in urological
examination techniques. The layers of
body-axis slices from the kidney to the
prostate gland can reconstruct images in
any plane or reconstruct 3-dimensional
images, allowing examination of parenchyma,
exit lines, renal pelvis, ureter administration,
bladder and prostate [1]. CT could also be
able to distinguish blood, fat, calcification,
necrosis, fluid, etc. In addition, CT with
intravenous contrast injection also helps
to determine more distinct structures,
such as vascular lesions, poor vascularity,
avascularity .and .renal .blood .vessels.
1. Viet Duc Hospital
Corresponding author: Nguyen Duc Minh (hienminh28bvvd@gmail.com)
Date received: 16/12/2019
Date accepted: 30/12/2019
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
213
CT 64-slides could render the renal blood
vessels, which is very valuable in the
treatment and prognosis of the kidney
disease. Moreover, the greatest benefit of
CT 64-slides is that it takes shorter shooting
time, produces better images and has less
noise than conventional CT [2].
In the patients with ureteropelvic
junction obstruction (UPJO), multidisciplinary
CT-scan with angiography and vascular
system rendering is considered as
gold-standard for diagnosing urological
pathologies. Currently, CT-scans are
more commonly used as diagnostic
imaging tools to diagnose UJPO rather
than UIV [3, 4]. CT-scans could provide
detailed information about the anatomy
and function of pathological kidneys,
clearly identify the location and severity of
stalemate of the junction and the
condition of the lower ureter. In addition,
CT-scan also helps to diagnose the
comorbidities of patients, such as poorly
contrasted stones or polyps. According to
Rabat et al, CT-scan helped to diagnose
variants of renal vascular blood vessels
with the sensitivity from 85 to 100%, and
detect abnormal blood vessels at the
junction with an accuracy of 83.3% [1].
The information provided from multidisciplinary
CT-scan is very important in the
preoperative diagnosis because it helps
the surgeon to decide the most appropriate
treatment method, access path and imaging
techniques for each specific case.
Vietnam has applied CT 64-slides scan
in supporting for diagnosis and treatment
of several diseases in both internal
medicine and surgery filed. However,
research evidences of role of CT-scan
64-slides among patients with UPJO still
limited across the country. This study
aims: To determine the sensitivity and
specificity of multidisciplinary CT in the
diagnosis of UPJO among patients who
underwent retroperitoneal laparoscopic
surgery at Viet Duc Hospital from 2012 to
2017.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
1. Subjects.
Study participants were patients
diagnosed with UJPO and undergoing
peritoneal laparoscopic surgery at Urology
Surgery Department, Viet Duc Hospital
from 2012 to 2017.
* Inclusion criteria:
- Adults with age ≥ 16.
- Having 64-slides CT-scanner’s urologic
imaging results before surgery.
- Having pre- and in-operative assessment.
* Exclusion criteria:
- Postoperative diagnosis was not UJPO.
- Acquired UJPO after surgery.
- Patients with chronic comorbidities
that may affect the surgery outcomes,
such as: heart failure, coronary artery disease,
liver failure, kidney failure, ankylosing
spondylitis, etc.
2. Methods.
* Study design:
We conducted a prospective study with
pre- and post-assessment before and
after surgery.
* Sample size:
A convenience sampling method has
been applied with all patients who met
the inclusion criteria were selected to
participate. A total of 62 patients were
enrolled to the study from 2012 to 2017.
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
214
* Study measurement:
- Demographic characteristics: We
collected data about age, gender and
employment status among participants at
the time of enrollment.
- Pre-surgical assessment: Clinical
manifestations, ultrasound and 64-slides
CT imaging were assessed at the baseline
to analyze the current status of urinary
system related to UJPO, included renal
pelvis diameter, the angle of renal pelvis
and ureter, the position of ureters coming
from renal pelvis and the abnormality of
renal artery.
- In-surgery assessment: We assessed
the damage of urinary system by
macroscopic and microscopic anatomy
with the similar indicators as mentioned
above in pre-surgery assessment.
- Post-surgery assessment: Clinical
progression of patients was assessed
after surgery, including patient's condition,
drainage, amount and nature of the urine.
Post-operative’s complications were also
collected.
* Statistical analysis:
Epi Data was used for data entry and
cleaning. All statistical analysis was made
by using STATA 14.0. Descriptive analysis
was used to describe the demographic,
clinical and imaging characteristics with
median and IQR for quantitative variables
and frequency and percentage for qualitative
variables.
We compared the renal pelvis diameter,
the angle of renal pelvis and ureter, the
position of ureters from renal pelvis and
the abnormality of renal artery between
image results obtained 64-slides CT-scanner
and actual assessment results in surgery.
Cohen's Kappa coefficient was used
to evaluate the agreement between
CT-scanner and in-surgery assessment.
Sensitivity and specificity were also
calculated to determine the reliability of
64-slides CT-scanner in diagnosing
damage of urinary system among patients
with UJPO.
* Ethical issues:
The research proposal was approved
by the review board of the Vietnam
Military Medical University. The study was
accepted by Viet Duc Hospital and
Vietnam Military Medical University. The
information in the research is completely
confidential and is used only for research
purposes.
RESULTS
Table 1: 64-slides CT-scanner imaging
results before surgery.
64-slides
CT-scanner
Frequency
(n = 62)
Percentage
(%)
The position of ureters from renal pelvis
Normal 47 75.8
High 15 24.2
The angle of renal pelvis and ureter
Sharp 14 22.6
Obtuse 48 77.4
The abnormality of renal artery
None 42 67.7
Yes 20 32.3
62 patients underwent CT imaging
before surgery, 24.2% had high angle of
renal pelvis and ureter. The proportion of
patients with sharp position of ureters from
renal pelvis was 22.6%. The abnormality
of renal artery was found in 32.3% of
participants.
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
215
Table 2: Comparison of renal pelvis
diameter between CT-scanner imaging
and in surgery assessment.
In-surgery
assessment 64-slides
CT imaging
< 35 mm ≥ 35 mm
Total
< 35 mm 35 1 36
≥ 35 mm 1 25 26
Total 36 26 62
Agreement 96.78%
Expected
agreement 51.3%
Cohen Kappa’s
score 0.9338
p-value < 0,001
Sensitivity 97.22%
Specificity 96.2%
High agreement of renal pelvis diameter
between 64-slides CT-scanner imaging
and in surgery assessment with the
agreement ratio was 96.78% and Cohen
Kappa’s score was 0.9338 (p < 0.001).
The sensitivity and specificity were 97.22%
and 96.2%, respectively.
Table 3: Comparison of the position
of ureters coming from renal pelvis
between CT-scanner imaging and on
surgery assessment.
In-surgery
assessment 64-slides
CT imaging
Normal High
Total
Normal 46 2 48
High 2 12 14
Total 48 14 62
Agreement 93.54%
Expected agreement 65.1%
Cohen Kappa’s
score 0.8155
p-value < 0.001
Sensitivity 85.71%
Specificity 95.83%
We found high agreement of the position
of ureters coming from renal pelvis
between 64-slides CT-scanner imaging
and in-surgery assessment. The agreement
ratio was very high (93.54%) and Cohen
Kappa’s score was 0.8155 (p < 0.001).
The sensitivity and specificity were also
high (85.71% and 95.83%).
Table 4: Comparison of the abnormality
of renal artery between CT-scanner
imaging and in-surgery assessment.
In-surgery
assessment 64-slides
CT imaging
None Yes
Total
None 41 1 42
Yes 4 16 20
Total 45 17 62
Agreement 91.94%
Expected
agreement 58.01%
Cohen Kappa’s
score 0.8079
p-value < 0.001
Sensitivity 80%
Specificity 97.62%
High agreement of abnormality of renal
artery was found between 64-slides
CT-scanner imaging and in-surgery
assessment. The agreement ratio was
91.94% and Cohen Kappa’s score was
0.8079 (p < 0.001). The sensitivity and
specificity were 80% and 97.62%.
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
216
DISCUSSION
The selection of treatment procedure
for UJPO depends on many factors,
including the renal function, the degree of
renal hydronephrosis and the length of
the stenosis segment [1]. Previously,
radiography of the urinary system with
intravenous contrast injection (UIV) was
widely used in the diagnosis of urological
diseases including UJPO [2]. However,
this method has many disadvantages,
such as high errors rate, patients may feel
uncomfortable and the image is not
sufficiently detailed for supporting the
diagnosis. This study was one of the
first researches to assess the role of
CT-scanner in diagnosing patients with
UJPO, as well as, calculate sensitivity and
specificity of CT-scanner in pre-surgery
assessment, compared with the macroscopic
and microscopic anatomy during surgery
[5, 6].
The image resolution density of CT is
much higher than conventional X-rays,
moreover, the enhanced contrast can cross
patients' areas of infection. In addition,
the urinary tract could also be clear
displayed in CT images. Results by
Kawamoto et al showed that CT not only
displayed obstruction ureter, but also the
location and the root of obstruction [7].
El-Nahas et al also reported similar results
that the obstruction of the ureteropelvic
that cannot be showed in the X-ray of
intravenous urinary system, could be seen
in CT-scanner in a group of 42 patients
with UJPO [8]. In study by Chong Xie
et al, the proportion of the visible of the
obstruction on CT-scan images was 90.2%,
much higher than the X-rays technique
(39.3%). Except for patients with completely
obstructed, CT-scanner may show most
of the urinary tract and the obstruction of
renal pelvis [9]. For patients with tumors
or kidney stones, CT-scanner could not
only show the urinary tract and fill the
defect of the tumor, but also reflected
the position and overall morphological
characteristics of the tumor, as well as the
condition of surrounding tissue. Consequently,
indirect diagnostic guesses can be avoided
by using CT-scanner and removed the
limitations in the X-ray urinary tract systems.
A further advantage of CT-scanner in the
diagnosis of UJPO is that the integrity,
morphology and perfusion of renal
parenchyma can be assessed in addition
to obtaining information about the spatial
orientation and presence of the disease.
Many studies had suggested that
CT-scanner should be considered as a
routine imaging technique in the diagnosis
and treatment of renal pelvic junction
obstruction [8]. The sensitivity of CT-scanner
in detecting the root cause of the obstruction
was determined to be 100%, much higher
than X-ray (74%) in group of patients with
chronic obstructive urological disease [10].
In our study, comparing the evaluation of
CT with the assessment during surgery,
the sensitivity and specificity of 64-slides
CT-scanner were above 85%, showing a
high value in pre-surgical diagnosis among
patients with UJPO. In the assessment of
renal pelvis diameter, the agreement
between CT-scanner imaging and the
macroscopic and microscopic anatomy
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
1-2020
217
during surgery was nearly 90%, and the
sensitivity and specificity were high at 97.2%
and 96.2%, respectively. The agreement
rate in identifying abnormality of renal
artery was also high at 91.94%, the
Kappa’s score was 0.8079 (p < 0.001).
The angle of renal pelvis and ureter
and the position of ureters coming from
renal pelvis were also found at high level
of sensitivity and specificity (> 85%).
The pre-operations play an important role
in selecting surgical methods and shortening
surgery time. Our results showed that
64-slides CT-scanner could be diagnosed
with the high accurate rate in comparison
with the in-surgery assessment. We suggested
CT-scanner should be considered as gold
standard for diagnosing and pre-surgery
assessing among patients with UJPO.
CONCLUSION
The 64-slides CT-scanner showed high
sensitivity and specificity in diagnosing the
damage of urinary system among patients
with UJPO undergoing retroperitoneal
laparoscopic surgery at Viet Duc Hospital
from 2012 to 2017. CT-scanner should
be performed for better diagnosis and
treatment and surgery planning in patients
with UJPO.
REFERENCES
1. Rabah D et al. Ureteropelvic junction
obstruction: Does CT angiography allow
better selection of therapeutic modalities and
better patient outcome? J Endourol. 2004, 18 (5),
pp.427-430.
2. Dikranian A.H et al. Intravenous
urography in evaluation of asymptomatic
microscopic hematuria. J Endourol. 2005, 19 (5),
pp.595-597.
3. Dalla Palma L, A. Morra, M. Grotto.
CT-urography. Radiol Med. 2005. 110 (3),
pp.170-178.
4. Martin X, O. Rouviere. Radiologic
evaluations affecting surgical technique in
ureteropelvic junction obstruction. Curr Opin
Urol. 2001, 11 (2), pp.193-196.
5. Conlin M.J. Results of selective
management of ureteropelvic junction obstruction.
J Endourol. 2002, 16 (4), pp.233-236.
6. Calder A.D et al. Contrast-enhanced
magnetic resonance angiography for the
detection of crossing renal vessels in children
with symptomatic ureteropelvic junction obstruction:
Comparison with operative findings. Pediatr
Radiol. 2007. 37 (4), pp.356-361.
7. Kawamoto S, K.M Horton, E.K Fishman.
Computed tomography urography with 16-
channel multidetector computed tomography:
A pictorial review. J Comput Assist Tomogr.
2004, 28 (5), pp.581-587.
8. El-Nahas A.R et al. Role of multiphasic
helical computed tomography in planning
surgical treatment for pelvi-ureteric junction
obstruction. BJU. 2004. 94 (4), pp.582-587.
9. Xie C et al. Comparison between
intravenous urography and computed tomography
urography in diagnosing ureteropelvic junction
obstruction. Nephro-urology monthly. 2011, 3 (4),
pp.258-263.
10. El-Ghar, M.E et al. Contrast-enhanced
spiral computerized tomography in patients
with chronic obstructive uropathy and normal
serum creatinine: A single session for
anatomical and functional assessment. J Urol.
2004, 172 (3), pp.985-988.
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
the_role_of_64_slides_computed_tomography_scan_in_preoperati.pdf