Detrital zircons from two Devonian
siliciclastic rocks, the Van Canh and the Van
Huong Formations from the Do Son Peninsular (NE Vietnam) were analyzed for U, Th,
and Pb isotopes by LA-SF ICP-MS techniques. The youngest zircon of each formation
exhibits maximum ages of sedimentation at
407.1±9.5 Ma (Van Canh Formation) and
406.3±4.0 Ma (Van Huong Formation) which
confirms published biostratigraphic age data.
The zircon cluster of both samples from the
east Red River Basin as well as palaeontological affinities to South China, confirms reconstructions for NE Vietnam close to the western Himalayas suggested by earlier studies.
Acknowledgements
The paper is a contribution to IGCP 596-
Climate Change and Biodiversity Patterns in
the Mid-Paleozoic (Early Devonian to Late
Carboniferous). Funding by the first-author
(P.K.) is acknowledged by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG Project KO-
1622/15-1). We thank both anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments
which helped to improve the manuscript. We
also thank Prof. Sarah K. Carmichael (Appalachian State University, Boone, USA) for
checking the English of the final version. Jana
Anger (Senckenberg - Research Institute and
Natural History Museum Frankfurt) is
thanked for preparing some figures.
21 trang |
Chia sẻ: honghp95 | Lượt xem: 526 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem trước 20 trang tài liệu U-Pb detrital zircon geochronology of sedimentary rocks in NE Vietnam: Implication for Early and Middle Devonian Palaeogeography, để xem tài liệu hoàn chỉnh bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
56 4.8 0.05593 3.4 0.69 409 13 415 16 450 77 91
c29 23202 256 18 0.52 3053 0.06558 2.6 0.49731 3.7 0.05500 2.6 0.70 409 10 410 12 412 59 99
c44 22600 346 24 0.32 41651 0.06543 3.3 0.49856 3.9 0.05526 2.1 0.84 409 13 411 13 423 48 97
c40 15315 211 15 0.27 23688 0.06800 2.7 0.52195 3.1 0.05567 1.6 0.86 424 11 426 11 439 36 97
b47 8277 201 15 0.41 15205 0.06821 3.4 0.52255 4.8 0.05556 3.4 0.71 425 14 427 17 435 75 98
b19 32280 417 30 0.34 58044 0.06855 2.0 0.53418 2.2 0.05652 0.7 0.94 427 8 435 8 473 17 90
b43 6358 139 9 0.22 11572 0.06849 2.6 0.52605 4.0 0.05571 3.0 0.66 427 11 429 14 441 68 97
c12 37937 425 31 0.38 11655 0.06907 3.4 0.53109 4.2 0.05577 2.4 0.82 431 14 433 15 443 54 97
c16 22708 276 22 0.61 8586 0.06908 2.7 0.52934 3.2 0.05557 1.8 0.84 431 11 431 11 435 39 99
b40 12935 254 19 0.40 23523 0.06966 2.3 0.53686 3.2 0.05589 2.1 0.73 434 10 436 11 448 48 97
c21 69039 519 39 0.29 2504 0.06976 3.4 0.53813 3.6 0.05595 1.3 0.93 435 14 437 13 450 29 97
b50 20881 515 38 0.32 37772 0.07102 3.0 0.54981 3.9 0.05615 2.4 0.78 442 13 445 14 458 54 96
b58 7593 206 15 0.29 13759 0.07103 2.6 0.54943 3.3 0.05610 2.2 0.77 442 11 445 12 456 48 97
b41 8778 220 17 0.39 15780 0.07110 2.5 0.55319 3.4 0.05643 2.3 0.74 443 11 447 12 469 50 94
b45 11178 271 20 0.31 20379 0.07109 2.6 0.54665 3.9 0.05577 2.9 0.67 443 11 443 14 443 65 100
c39 18780 264 20 0.37 34158 0.07126 3.0 0.54912 3.7 0.05589 2.2 0.80 444 13 444 14 448 50 99
c17 8409 89 7 0.42 14831 0.07193 2.8 0.55701 3.4 0.05616 1.9 0.83 448 12 450 12 459 42 98
c33 35564 461 35 0.29 39095 0.07358 2.8 0.56936 3.3 0.05612 1.7 0.85 458 12 458 12 457 38 100
a6 18384 219 16 0.28 33020 0.07390 1.7 0.57568 2.0 0.05650 0.9 0.89 460 8 462 7 472 20 97
c32 26474 340 25 0.22 11354 0.07399 2.8 0.57467 3.6 0.05633 2.2 0.79 460 13 461 13 466 49 99
c14 17991 205 15 0.24 32363 0.07417 2.8 0.57761 3.3 0.05648 1.8 0.85 461 13 463 12 471 39 98
b32 9386 170 13 0.39 16769 0.07468 2.6 0.58238 5.7 0.05656 5.0 0.45 464 12 466 21 474 111 98
b55 8668 229 18 0.35 15611 0.07478 2.4 0.58142 3.4 0.05639 2.4 0.71 465 11 465 13 468 52 99
c31 16079 222 17 0.40 10133 0.07502 2.9 0.58516 3.5 0.05657 2.1 0.81 466 13 468 13 475 46 98
b3 13794 198 15 0.37 8281 0.07511 2.3 0.59127 3.2 0.05709 2.3 0.70 467 10 472 12 495 50 94
b54 12904 335 25 0.22 23308 0.07515 2.4 0.58437 3.7 0.05640 2.7 0.66 467 11 467 14 468 61 100
b53 7700 177 14 0.38 3912 0.07535 2.6 0.59396 6.2 0.05717 5.7 0.41 468 12 473 24 498 126 94
c18 7980 92 7 0.32 14136 0.07528 2.8 0.59613 3.4 0.05743 1.9 0.83 468 13 475 13 508 42 92
b33 4505 88 8 0.64 5576 0.07552 2.3 0.58862 4.4 0.05653 3.7 0.53 469 10 470 17 473 82 99
a7 7469 75 6 0.45 1460 0.07563 2.0 0.58978 4.4 0.05656 4.0 0.44 470 9 471 17 474 88 99
a8 20677 258 20 0.27 21145 0.07573 1.7 0.58984 3.1 0.05649 2.6 0.56 471 8 471 12 472 57 100
c50 17715 272 21 0.23 31793 0.07574 3.9 0.59216 4.6 0.05671 2.4 0.85 471 18 472 17 480 53 98
b42 9459 167 14 0.44 16780 0.07602 2.4 0.60004 3.5 0.05724 2.5 0.70 472 11 477 13 501 54 94
c11 13914 152 12 0.28 24983 0.07603 3.2 0.59195 3.8 0.05647 2.1 0.84 472 15 472 15 471 46 100
b28 13190 211 16 0.14 23567 0.07670 2.2 0.60179 2.8 0.05690 1.7 0.79 476 10 478 11 488 37 98
b30 12907 233 19 0.56 23149 0.07667 3.0 0.59948 4.5 0.05671 3.3 0.67 476 14 477 17 480 73 99
c22 8658 97 8 0.54 5150 0.07656 3.0 0.59700 4.7 0.05656 3.6 0.64 476 14 475 18 474 79 100
b51 4665 111 9 0.32 6216 0.07675 2.6 0.60730 5.2 0.05739 4.5 0.50 477 12 482 20 506 99 94
c1 7782 71 7 0.77 13797 0.07677 2.9 0.60455 4.3 0.05712 3.1 0.68 477 13 480 16 496 69 96
c23 19571 235 19 0.34 7623 0.07687 2.8 0.60308 3.3 0.05690 1.7 0.85 477 13 479 13 488 38 98
c30 7044 81 7 0.51 12602 0.07700 3.1 0.60483 4.8 0.05697 3.7 0.64 478 14 480 19 490 81 98
b15 4257 61 5 0.45 7590 0.07734 2.1 0.60858 3.6 0.05707 2.9 0.59 480 10 483 14 494 64 97
b18 8455 118 9 0.26 15195 0.07722 2.4 0.60663 13.6 0.05697 13.4 0.18 480 11 481 54 491 296 98
b21 23377 417 33 0.45 4376 0.07735 2.6 0.60594 3.3 0.05682 2.0 0.80 480 12 481 13 484 43 99
b57 3740 95 8 0.42 6639 0.07726 2.5 0.60918 4.7 0.05718 4.0 0.52 480 11 483 18 499 88 96
a1 7229 96 8 0.39 6827 0.07771 2.4 0.61336 3.0 0.05724 1.9 0.78 482 11 486 12 501 42 96
b27 11280 167 13 0.14 14484 0.07818 2.4 0.61805 3.3 0.05733 2.2 0.74 485 11 489 13 504 49 96
b10 9732 141 11 0.29 17282 0.07825 2.1 0.61611 5.1 0.05710 4.6 0.40 486 10 487 20 496 102 98
b5 10435 149 13 0.51 18609 0.07864 3.8 0.61854 5.0 0.05704 3.2 0.77 488 18 489 19 493 70 99
c45 7774 108 9 0.23 2456 0.07909 3.1 0.62292 3.7 0.05712 2.1 0.82 491 15 492 15 496 47 99
Königshof P., et al./Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences 39 (2017)
312
b12 5919 85 7 0.29 10489 0.07941 2.6 0.62618 4.0 0.05719 3.0 0.66 493 12 494 16 499 67 99
c3 10098 95 9 0.57 17791 0.07968 3.0 0.63427 4.8 0.05773 3.7 0.64 494 14 499 19 520 81 95
c15 9115 89 8 0.39 16242 0.07969 3.2 0.62704 3.9 0.05707 2.2 0.82 494 15 494 15 494 49 100
b31 5610 103 9 0.45 9888 0.08042 2.7 0.63827 7.7 0.05756 7.3 0.34 499 13 501 31 513 160 97
b52 19621 391 38 0.53 18053 0.08712 3.3 0.70977 3.8 0.05909 1.8 0.88 538 17 545 16 570 39 94
c5 11309 119 12 0.87 440 0.09037 2.8 0.73995 6.0 0.05939 5.3 0.46 558 15 562 26 581 115 96
b1 4807 59 6 0.41 4464 0.09547 1.9 0.78555 9.8 0.05967 9.6 0.19 588 10 589 45 592 208 99
c4 10498 78 8 0.23 17639 0.09969 3.7 0.82948 4.6 0.06034 2.7 0.81 613 22 613 22 616 59 99
c37 15024 129 15 0.45 25045 0.10350 3.0 0.86903 3.6 0.06090 1.9 0.85 635 18 635 17 636 41 100
b36 6375 75 9 0.33 10406 0.11107 2.5 0.95219 4.3 0.06218 3.5 0.58 679 16 679 21 680 74 100
c10 37845 207 29 0.80 1413 0.11307 3.0 0.98677 4.0 0.06330 2.5 0.77 691 20 697 20 718 54 96
b60 8701 142 18 0.54 13798 0.11506 2.1 1.01722 4.1 0.06412 3.5 0.52 702 14 713 21 746 74 94
b49 7030 79 13 1.21 11232 0.11702 2.9 1.02113 4.7 0.06329 3.7 0.62 713 20 714 24 718 78 99
b26 7123 57 10 0.96 11087 0.12363 4.7 1.11078 7.4 0.06516 5.7 0.63 751 33 759 40 780 121 96
a3 19269 106 13 0.35 29298 0.12549 2.1 1.15922 2.9 0.06700 2.0 0.72 762 15 782 16 838 42 91
c38 15308 122 19 0.50 16917 0.14109 2.8 1.31767 4.0 0.06773 2.8 0.71 851 23 853 23 860 58 99
b24 14347 110 20 0.96 21315 0.14379 2.3 1.35643 2.8 0.06842 1.5 0.83 866 19 870 16 881 32 98
c35 24908 136 21 0.31 10028 0.14713 3.2 1.41194 4.1 0.06960 2.6 0.78 885 26 894 25 917 53 97
b2 15212 77 13 0.47 22034 0.15056 3.0 1.45627 3.8 0.07015 2.4 0.77 904 25 912 23 933 50 97
b29 6277 35 7 1.03 9050 0.15388 2.8 1.49229 5.6 0.07034 4.8 0.51 923 24 927 35 938 99 98
c8 25655 107 20 0.52 36359 0.16094 2.8 1.59844 3.3 0.07203 1.7 0.85 962 25 970 21 987 35 97
b22 40883 407 62 0.15 56775 0.16114 2.6 1.63117 3.9 0.07342 2.9 0.67 963 23 982 25 1026 58 94
b11 84172 478 80 0.32 21121 0.16130 2.8 1.59912 3.2 0.07190 1.6 0.87 964 25 970 20 983 32 98
c47 91234 490 79 0.25 6219 0.16220 2.6 1.60812 3.2 0.07191 1.9 0.80 969 23 973 20 983 39 99
b8 35027 169 30 0.41 49368 0.16247 2.2 1.61489 2.7 0.07209 1.6 0.82 971 20 976 17 988 32 98
c13 57925 221 40 0.43 81587 0.16594 2.8 1.65029 3.1 0.07213 1.4 0.89 990 25 990 20 990 29 100
c34 34857 156 30 0.49 18600 0.17380 3.2 1.79069 4.0 0.07473 2.3 0.81 1033 31 1042 26 1061 47 97
b16 11254 48 11 0.96 15409 0.17657 2.4 1.80454 3.8 0.07412 2.9 0.64 1048 24 1047 25 1045 59 100
b9 24566 110 21 0.44 33687 0.17664 2.2 1.80499 2.7 0.07411 1.6 0.81 1049 22 1047 18 1044 32 100
c2 31933 108 19 0.15 43805 0.18029 2.7 1.84170 3.0 0.07409 1.4 0.88 1069 26 1060 20 1044 29 102
c48 50730 247 49 0.39 68274 0.18034 2.9 1.87705 3.2 0.07549 1.3 0.92 1069 29 1073 21 1082 26 99
c24 126515 470 82 0.12 30177 0.18181 2.6 1.88881 2.9 0.07535 1.2 0.91 1077 26 1077 19 1078 24 100
b46 10415 80 18 0.82 13965 0.18213 2.2 1.90864 3.5 0.07600 2.7 0.63 1079 22 1084 23 1095 54 98
b34 5868 37 7 0.63 7352 0.18453 2.6 1.99016 7.6 0.07822 7.1 0.34 1092 26 1112 53 1152 142 95
c20 30855 94 22 0.83 40148 0.18489 2.9 1.98970 3.9 0.07805 2.5 0.76 1094 30 1112 26 1148 50 95
b14 27313 114 23 0.43 36441 0.18544 2.4 1.94603 3.3 0.07611 2.2 0.74 1097 24 1097 22 1098 44 100
c42 80693 327 73 0.63 5567 0.18579 2.8 1.97393 3.4 0.07706 2.0 0.82 1099 29 1107 23 1123 39 98
b25 3178 17 3 0.31 4008 0.18884 2.5 2.07322 11.9 0.07963 11.6 0.21 1115 25 1140 85 1188 229 94
a4 23696 69 18 1.17 30918 0.19384 2.4 2.07776 3.2 0.07774 2.0 0.77 1142 25 1141 22 1140 40 100
c41 14156 50 13 0.88 18000 0.20036 4.4 2.20762 4.8 0.07991 2.0 0.91 1177 47 1183 34 1195 39 99
c19 41031 106 28 0.84 51886 0.20227 3.2 2.23365 3.7 0.08009 1.9 0.86 1187 35 1192 26 1199 38 99
b17 24945 70 20 0.72 15755 0.23802 2.4 2.87190 3.0 0.08751 1.8 0.79 1376 30 1375 23 1372 35 100
c28 139381 389 107 0.54 8792 0.24815 2.7 3.09497 3.1 0.09046 1.5 0.87 1429 35 1431 24 1435 29 100
b39 10398 35 14 1.69 11350 0.25251 2.8 3.23544 3.7 0.09293 2.4 0.75 1451 36 1466 29 1486 46 98
c36 98148 211 61 0.83 4771 0.27020 3.3 3.67386 3.8 0.09861 1.9 0.87 1542 45 1566 31 1598 35 96
b44 20776 68 23 1.03 4467 0.28452 2.2 3.97263 2.6 0.10127 1.5 0.82 1614 31 1629 22 1647 28 98
c46 165247 331 104 0.34 37977 0.29087 3.5 4.06053 4.2 0.10125 2.4 0.83 1646 51 1646 35 1647 44 100
c9 31121 42 14 0.37 30876 0.29370 2.6 4.14834 3.5 0.10244 2.4 0.74 1660 38 1664 29 1669 44 99
b35 17232 42 15 0.67 16555 0.30133 2.7 4.38985 3.2 0.10566 1.7 0.84 1698 40 1710 27 1726 32 98
b23 51782 104 33 0.17 49762 0.31690 2.3 4.62523 40.1 0.10585 40.0 0.06 1775 36 1754 406 1729 734 103
c7 164253 208 76 0.41 146745 0.32323 3.3 5.06962 3.5 0.11375 1.1 0.95 1805 52 1831 30 1860 20 97
b56 121788 207 113 0.56 77982 0.45765 3.1 10.01660 3.3 0.15874 1.2 0.93 2429 63 2436 31 2442 21 99
c6 360239 234 135 0.83 225570 0.47007 2.6 10.52845 2.9 0.16244 1.3 0.90 2484 55 2482 28 2481 22 100
c43 238053 184 112 0.67 138532 0.47496 2.5 11.45528 4.5 0.17492 3.7 0.57 2505 53 2561 42 2605 61 96
b4 113652 81 46 0.53 31352 0.47527 2.3 10.97481 2.6 0.16748 1.2 0.88 2507 47 2521 24 2533 20 99
c49 168836 50 48 0.73 59281 0.69227 4.0 27.59714 4.2 0.28913 1.2 0.96 3391 107 3405 42 3413 18 99
awithin-run background-corrected mean 207Pb signal in counts per second; bU and Pb content and Th/U ratio were calculated relative to GJ-1
and are accurate to approximately 10%; ccorrected for background, mass bias, laser induced U-Pb fractionation and common Pb (if detecta-
ble, see analytical method) using Stacey & Kramers (1975) model Pb composition. 207Pb/235U calculated using 207Pb/206Pb/(238U/206Pb ×
1/137.88). Errors are propagated by quadratic addition of within-run errors (2SE) and the reproducibility of GJ-1 (2SD); dRho is the error
correlation defined as err206Pb/238U/err207Pb/235
Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences, 39(4), 303-323
313
Table 2. Zircon U-Pb analytical data of sample VN24, n = 96 of 120 measured zircon grains, sandstone (Do Son
group, Van Canh Formation, Early Devonian; location: Do Son Peninsula, Vietnam: (N20°42’36,1’’;
E106°47’02,4’’)
Number
207Pba
(cps)
Ub
(ppm)
Pbb
(ppm)
Thb
U
206Pbc
204Pb
206Pbc
238U
2
%
207Pbc
235U
2
%
207Pbc
206Pb
2
% rho
d 206Pb 238U
2
(Ma)
207Pb
235U
2
(Ma)
207Pb
206Pb
2
(Ma) conc %
a26 5134 123 8 0.35 9504 0.06505 3.6 0.49377 4.7 0.05506 3.0 0.78 406 14 407 16 414 66 98
c7 25486 516 34 0.31 15818 0.06507 2.5 0.50589 4.0 0.05639 3.2 0.62 406 10 416 14 468 70 87
a17 23382 495 34 0.28 43515 0.06525 5.1 0.49373 6.4 0.05488 3.8 0.80 407 20 407 22 407 85 100
a50 5331 189 15 0.71 9913 0.06528 4.4 0.49408 5.5 0.05489 3.3 0.80 408 17 408 19 408 74 100
b39 14431 240 17 0.27 26365 0.06666 2.2 0.51046 4.5 0.05554 3.9 0.49 416 9 419 15 434 87 96
d8 25755 398 28 0.34 29892 0.06665 2.8 0.51232 3.8 0.05575 2.6 0.74 416 11 420 13 442 57 94
c1 10823 161 13 0.68 19834 0.06731 3.5 0.51596 4.0 0.05560 2.0 0.87 420 14 422 14 436 44 96
b22 36912 594 44 0.39 67828 0.06754 4.3 0.51706 5.9 0.05552 4.0 0.74 421 18 423 20 433 88 97
b43 617 10 1 0.45 599 0.06751 3.8 0.88699 12.4 0.09529 11.8 0.30 421 15 645 61 1534 222 27
a59 13789 588 39 0.16 25434 0.06766 4.8 0.51513 6.0 0.05522 3.5 0.80 422 20 422 21 421 79 100
d12 13379 221 16 0.39 24506 0.06766 4.5 0.52096 5.1 0.05584 2.3 0.89 422 18 426 18 446 52 95
b11 10601 126 9 0.40 19354 0.06790 2.6 0.51952 4.1 0.05549 3.2 0.63 423 11 425 14 432 71 98
a20 22106 436 32 0.39 40584 0.06891 3.3 0.52782 3.8 0.05555 2.0 0.86 430 14 430 13 434 44 99
a19 9977 185 14 0.43 18281 0.07007 3.6 0.54069 4.5 0.05597 2.7 0.80 437 15 439 16 451 61 97
a37 8942 179 14 0.47 7871 0.07012 3.4 0.54063 4.7 0.05592 3.2 0.73 437 15 439 17 449 71 97
a10 8503 127 9 0.25 15438 0.07033 3.3 0.54447 3.9 0.05615 2.2 0.84 438 14 441 14 458 48 96
a14 10688 191 14 0.38 19592 0.07023 3.5 0.53900 4.3 0.05566 2.4 0.82 438 15 438 15 439 54 100
d4 24771 387 28 0.30 22295 0.07052 3.4 0.54416 4.6 0.05597 3.0 0.75 439 15 441 17 451 67 97
a22 6940 141 11 0.43 12602 0.07100 3.5 0.55042 6.1 0.05622 4.9 0.58 442 15 445 22 461 109 96
a11 8175 134 10 0.28 14752 0.07111 3.7 0.55212 4.9 0.05631 3.2 0.76 443 16 446 18 465 70 95
b27 28401 430 33 0.40 14515 0.07178 3.9 0.55395 4.4 0.05597 2.1 0.88 447 17 448 16 451 46 99
b16 16855 236 18 0.39 30312 0.07243 3.4 0.56185 4.2 0.05626 2.5 0.81 451 15 453 15 463 55 97
a53 7232 238 20 0.50 1822 0.07377 4.2 0.63509 12.2 0.06244 11.4 0.35 459 19 499 49 689 243 67
b33 14105 235 19 0.50 8039 0.07403 3.6 0.57400 5.9 0.05623 4.7 0.60 460 16 461 22 462 105 100
a32 15457 360 27 0.27 28066 0.07419 3.4 0.57497 3.9 0.05621 1.9 0.87 461 15 461 15 461 42 100
b24 14081 163 13 0.47 9300 0.07436 2.3 0.58027 3.4 0.05660 2.5 0.69 462 10 465 13 476 55 97
b18 11121 171 14 0.36 19698 0.07471 4.2 0.58977 5.2 0.05726 3.0 0.82 464 19 471 20 501 66 93
c4 15969 252 19 0.16 2778 0.07487 3.6 0.58613 4.6 0.05678 2.9 0.78 465 16 468 17 483 64 96
b14 10380 141 11 0.36 18635 0.07588 2.7 0.59076 3.6 0.05647 2.3 0.76 471 12 471 14 471 51 100
a25 26312 453 35 0.30 28811 0.07603 7.4 0.59349 8.9 0.05662 5.0 0.83 472 34 473 34 477 110 99
a57 4447 170 13 0.30 7873 0.07676 4.3 0.60799 6.5 0.05745 4.8 0.67 477 20 482 25 509 106 94
d3 20465 310 23 0.20 36690 0.07701 3.0 0.60701 5.1 0.05717 4.1 0.59 478 14 482 20 498 90 96
a36 12549 310 26 0.50 22497 0.07709 3.3 0.60378 3.8 0.05681 2.0 0.86 479 15 480 15 484 43 99
b28 13514 201 16 0.29 24497 0.07713 3.2 0.60542 4.3 0.05693 2.9 0.73 479 15 481 17 489 65 98
a42 3943 113 10 0.48 7063 0.07813 3.4 0.61363 3.9 0.05696 1.8 0.88 485 16 486 15 490 40 99
a23 7012 124 12 0.55 12530 0.07840 3.6 0.61789 6.1 0.05716 5.0 0.58 487 17 489 24 498 110 98
b29 21129 312 26 0.35 37620 0.07869 4.4 0.61879 5.2 0.05703 2.8 0.85 488 21 489 20 493 61 99
b53 228 4 0 0.19 135 0.07866 3.8 0.89960 34.9 0.08295 34.7 0.11 488 18 652 183 1268 677 38
a45 3440 122 10 0.38 6227 0.07892 3.5 0.61297 4.6 0.05633 2.9 0.77 490 17 485 18 465 64 105
b32 9019 136 13 0.66 5605 0.07899 2.5 0.62454 4.3 0.05734 3.5 0.59 490 12 493 17 505 76 97
a41 4250 112 10 0.55 7757 0.08026 3.4 0.62409 5.4 0.05640 4.2 0.63 498 16 492 21 468 93 106
b19 8463 101 9 0.32 13439 0.08546 2.4 0.69530 3.6 0.05900 2.6 0.69 529 12 536 15 567 57 93
a29 4416 77 7 0.32 7735 0.08568 4.6 0.68706 5.5 0.05816 2.9 0.84 530 23 531 23 536 65 99
a47 5028 155 14 0.55 4440 0.08715 3.9 0.70149 5.3 0.05838 3.6 0.73 539 20 540 22 544 79 99
b35 9014 118 12 0.63 4351 0.08775 1.8 0.70648 4.5 0.05839 4.1 0.41 542 10 543 19 544 89 100
b40 20438 281 28 0.56 35537 0.08765 3.2 0.70541 4.0 0.05837 2.5 0.79 542 16 542 17 544 54 100
b30 16506 184 17 0.26 27820 0.09184 3.1 0.75172 3.7 0.05937 2.0 0.84 566 17 569 16 581 44 98
a33 4767 74 9 0.73 7972 0.10129 4.0 0.85068 5.7 0.06091 4.0 0.71 622 24 625 27 636 87 98
d1 6009 51 6 0.37 10101 0.10170 3.4 0.85786 4.6 0.06118 3.1 0.74 624 20 629 22 646 67 97
b13 31450 268 33 0.20 50044 0.11261 6.0 0.98981 7.2 0.06375 4.1 0.83 688 39 699 37 733 86 94
a18 10380 93 12 0.44 16526 0.11696 4.1 1.03021 4.7 0.06388 2.4 0.86 713 28 719 25 738 51 97
b21 14283 116 14 0.33 17920 0.11773 1.6 1.03809 4.7 0.06395 4.4 0.35 717 11 723 24 740 93 97
b23 12556 91 11 0.27 4710 0.11917 2.8 1.04542 3.6 0.06362 2.2 0.78 726 19 727 19 729 47 100
Königshof P., et al./Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences 39 (2017)
314
a56 9053 162 22 0.46 14430 0.11999 5.5 1.06150 7.4 0.06416 4.9 0.75 731 38 735 39 747 104 98
b12 8552 59 11 1.24 6977 0.12009 4.5 1.06850 6.5 0.06453 4.6 0.70 731 31 738 35 759 97 96
b2 15756 93 14 0.61 24510 0.12899 4.8 1.15841 5.4 0.06513 2.3 0.90 782 36 781 30 779 49 100
b36 9116 67 12 0.91 13827 0.13292 3.7 1.22574 4.8 0.06688 3.0 0.78 804 28 812 27 834 62 96
a46 18542 260 37 0.33 28770 0.13300 4.0 1.21017 5.1 0.06599 3.2 0.77 805 30 805 29 806 68 100
b7 10001 47 7 0.39 15175 0.13337 2.9 1.23248 4.0 0.06702 2.8 0.72 807 22 815 23 839 58 96
a38 25092 282 40 0.29 23507 0.13626 3.7 1.24895 4.1 0.06648 1.7 0.90 823 29 823 23 821 36 100
a27 36007 261 40 0.44 512 0.13749 4.1 1.27060 8.5 0.06703 7.4 0.48 830 32 833 49 839 155 99
a24 7875 70 10 0.40 11928 0.14028 3.6 1.30216 4.2 0.06732 2.2 0.86 846 29 847 25 848 46 100
a21 29205 231 34 0.33 43921 0.14131 3.7 1.32286 4.8 0.06790 3.0 0.77 852 29 856 28 865 63 98
b26 55573 353 55 0.44 83483 0.14124 2.7 1.31417 3.2 0.06748 1.8 0.83 852 21 852 19 853 38 100
a1 6179 33 7 1.12 8883 0.15300 3.4 1.49751 4.0 0.07098 2.1 0.84 918 29 929 25 957 44 96
a7 8266 37 7 0.81 11796 0.15456 5.1 1.52638 6.0 0.07162 3.2 0.84 926 44 941 38 975 66 95
b37 40415 268 43 0.30 21301 0.15765 3.8 1.57489 4.4 0.07245 2.2 0.86 944 33 960 28 999 45 95
a9 32654 173 30 0.45 47026 0.15853 3.4 1.54991 3.9 0.07091 1.9 0.87 949 30 950 24 955 38 99
a6 21096 101 19 0.63 29839 0.15876 3.7 1.57960 4.1 0.07216 1.8 0.90 950 33 962 26 991 36 96
b31 79765 428 76 0.44 112030 0.15955 3.8 1.58789 4.9 0.07218 3.1 0.77 954 34 965 31 991 64 96
a30 7001 52 13 1.57 9986 0.16149 3.5 1.59404 4.8 0.07159 3.3 0.73 965 32 968 31 974 68 99
a60 8359 132 20 0.09 6149 0.16249 3.1 1.60905 4.4 0.07182 3.2 0.69 971 28 974 28 981 65 99
a34 34879 432 66 0.06 5849 0.16330 4.7 1.64701 5.3 0.07315 2.6 0.88 975 42 988 34 1018 52 96
a2 104468 618 107 0.33 11909 0.16678 3.9 1.74540 4.8 0.07590 2.7 0.82 994 36 1025 31 1092 55 91
b6 22976 100 19 0.44 30886 0.16802 3.3 1.68216 4.1 0.07261 2.4 0.81 1001 31 1002 27 1003 50 100
d5 38954 171 31 0.36 3626 0.16854 3.0 1.69451 3.7 0.07292 2.3 0.79 1004 28 1006 24 1012 46 99
b10 44446 222 39 0.26 60280 0.16898 1.7 1.74359 3.5 0.07483 3.1 0.47 1007 16 1025 23 1064 63 95
a40 21336 214 37 0.27 29623 0.16995 3.0 1.72087 3.3 0.07344 1.3 0.91 1012 28 1016 21 1026 27 99
b38 19865 84 17 0.65 27801 0.17026 1.6 1.69615 3.7 0.07225 3.3 0.45 1014 15 1007 24 993 67 102
a55 57055 848 143 0.13 13945 0.17083 6.5 1.77232 8.8 0.07524 5.9 0.74 1017 62 1035 59 1075 118 95
b4 24293 118 21 0.27 32739 0.17461 5.9 1.78522 6.9 0.07415 3.6 0.85 1037 57 1040 46 1046 73 99 a44 5124 49 12 1.16 6759 0.17495 4.7 1.86469 5.1 0.07730 1.9 0.92 1039 45 1069 34 1129 39 92
b17 76436 356 60 0.08 57563 0.17656 3.0 1.82790 3.5 0.07509 1.7 0.86 1048 29 1056 23 1071 35 98
a28 81832 567 97 0.06 109701 0.17973 3.4 1.87765 4.5 0.07577 3.0 0.75 1066 33 1073 30 1089 60 98
c2 71217 398 72 0.19 4716 0.18156 3.1 1.95170 13.3 0.07796 12.9 0.23 1076 30 1099 93 1146 256 94
a16 41484 216 44 0.47 52644 0.18455 2.9 2.04743 5.2 0.08046 4.4 0.55 1092 29 1131 36 1208 86 90
a48 15535 146 29 0.25 11676 0.19060 3.8 2.10031 5.3 0.07992 3.7 0.73 1125 40 1149 37 1195 72 94
d7 65941 292 61 0.46 86911 0.19191 2.4 2.05778 3.1 0.07777 2.0 0.78 1132 25 1135 21 1141 39 99
b1 36807 129 26 0.27 46715 0.19236 2.5 2.09797 5.4 0.07910 4.8 0.45 1134 26 1148 38 1175 96 97
a31 60330 472 99 0.39 77591 0.19822 3.1 2.17485 3.5 0.07958 1.7 0.87 1166 33 1173 25 1186 34 98
a3 32497 122 28 0.47 41166 0.20461 3.5 2.26842 3.9 0.08041 1.7 0.90 1200 38 1203 28 1207 34 99
b20 72276 703 137 0.01 6644 0.20703 1.6 2.42291 8.9 0.08488 8.8 0.18 1213 18 1249 66 1313 170 92
a39 34447 208 46 0.25 42863 0.20922 3.8 2.36523 4.3 0.08199 2.0 0.88 1225 42 1232 31 1245 39 98
a5 104195 383 89 0.40 20818 0.21036 4.6 2.37808 4.9 0.08199 1.6 0.95 1231 52 1236 35 1245 31 99
a8 40168 137 34 0.48 48411 0.22342 3.9 2.61042 4.3 0.08474 1.7 0.91 1300 46 1304 32 1310 34 99
c6 100953 277 74 0.40 112644 0.24417 2.7 3.07637 3.0 0.09138 1.4 0.89 1408 34 1427 23 1454 26 97
b25 42053 96 30 0.56 44505 0.26914 2.3 3.55415 3.0 0.09578 2.0 0.76 1536 32 1539 24 1543 37 100
a15 21301 49 15 0.49 22266 0.27602 6.0 3.71575 6.4 0.09763 2.2 0.94 1571 85 1575 53 1579 42 99
d10 67455 140 45 0.60 21523 0.27857 2.1 3.90814 2.5 0.10175 1.3 0.86 1584 30 1615 20 1656 23 96
d11 67124 140 45 0.61 26819 0.27941 2.3 3.92210 2.6 0.10181 1.2 0.88 1588 32 1618 21 1657 23 96
a54 52720 313 102 0.49 53234 0.28302 3.9 3.94019 4.3 0.10097 1.7 0.92 1607 56 1622 35 1642 32 98
a4 97940 201 63 0.31 96102 0.29719 3.3 4.24251 3.6 0.10353 1.4 0.92 1677 49 1682 30 1688 26 99
b34 60089 104 37 0.34 23953 0.32196 3.5 4.95868 4.2 0.11170 2.3 0.84 1799 56 1812 36 1827 41 98
a58 81843 325 127 0.29 68373 0.36264 4.3 6.10709 4.8 0.12214 2.1 0.90 1995 75 1991 43 1988 37 100
a51 99017 296 146 0.56 27901 0.42433 3.4 9.05001 4.3 0.15469 2.5 0.81 2280 66 2343 40 2398 43 95
a35 170185 299 169 0.80 108202 0.44599 4.5 9.86129 4.9 0.16037 2.0 0.91 2377 89 2422 46 2460 35 97
a49 215623 421 222 0.36 136660 0.46354 3.4 10.31402 4.5 0.16138 3.0 0.75 2455 69 2463 43 2470 50 99
b3 280638 165 87 0.36 165754 0.46549 1.7 10.95972 6.6 0.17076 6.4 0.26 2464 36 2520 64 2565 107 96
a13 189127 166 83 0.09 112803 0.47614 3.4 11.22270 3.5 0.17095 1.0 0.96 2510 70 2542 33 2567 17 98
a52 61345 113 61 0.28 35983 0.48023 4.2 11.52951 5.6 0.17413 3.7 0.76 2528 89 2567 54 2598 61 97
b8 110427 68 42 0.54 63532 0.49850 3.0 12.13716 3.4 0.17658 1.6 0.88 2607 64 2615 32 2621 26 99
awithin-run background-corrected mean 207Pb signal in counts per second; bU and Pb content and Th/U ratio were calculated relative
to GJ-1 and are accurate to approximately 10%; ccorrected for background, mass bias, laser induced U-Pb fractionation and common
Pb (if detectable, see analytical method) using Stacey & Kramers (1975) model Pb composition. 207Pb/235U calculated using
207Pb/206Pb/(238U/206Pb × 1/137.88). Errors are propagated by quadratic addition of within-run errors (2SE) and the reproducibility of
GJ-1 (2SD); dRho is the error correlation defined as err206Pb/238U/err207Pb/235
Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences, 39(4), 303-323
315
Table 3. Age ranges and percentage of detrital zircons in
the samples VN23 (Van Huong Formation) and VN24
(Van Canh Formation). The 207Pb/206Pb age was taken for
interpretation for all zircons >1.0 Ga, and the 206Pb/238U
ages for younger grains. The applied stratigraphic time
scale is based on data published in Ogg et al. (2016)
Range(Ma) VN23 (%) VN24 (%)
Lower Devonian 393-419 4.6 4.7
Silurian 419-444 12 11.3
Ordovician 444-485 28.9 12.3
Cambrian 485-541 7.4 8.5
Neoproterozoic 541-1000 19.4 28.2
Mesoproterozoic 1000-1600 17.6 24.5
Palaeoproterozoic 1600-2500 7.4 7.5
Archaean 2500-4000 2.7 2.8
Concordia plots and concordia age of the
youngest zircon population of detrital zircons
of sample VN23 and VN24 are displayed in
Figures 6 and 7. All analysis of the zircons are
concordant with a range from the Archean
(~2500 Ma) to Palaeozoic (~400 Ma) in both
samples. The age distribution of zircon grains
in sample VN24 from the Van Canh Formation
is more complex with multiple age peaks com-
pared to those in sample VN23 from the Van
Huong Formation. The largest group of zir-
cons in sample VN24 belong to the Palaeozo-
ic age, ranging from 541 Ma to 393 Ma
(36,8%, Table 1). The main peaks in the prob-
ability plot occur at 437 Ma and 476 Ma,
which are flanked by a minor peak at 537 Ma.
Neoproterozoic zircons with age ranging
from 541 Ma to 1000 Ma represent the second
largest group with 28.2%, followed by Meso-
proterozoic zircons with age ranging from
1000 Ma to 1600 Ma (24.5%). The main
peaks of Neoproterozoic zircon grains lie at
~720 Ma and ~810 Ma. A large peak of
Mesoproterozoic zircon grains is found at
~1020 Ma. 7.5% of the zircon population
from sample VN24 show a Palaeoproterozoic
age (Table 3) with distinct peaks at ~1580 Ma
and 2450 Ma (Figure 8). A few zircons (2.8%)
yield the Archaean age (Table 3).
Figure 6. Concordia plots and concordia age of the
youngest zircon population of detrital zircon of sample
VN23
Königshof P., et al./Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences 39 (2017)
316
Figure 7. Concordia plots and concordia age of the
youngest zircon population of detrital zircon of
sample VN24
The age spectrum of zircon grains in sample
VN23 from the Van Huong Formation is com-
parable to that of sample VN24, but also
exhibits some differences. The sample shows a
large number of Palaeozoic zircon grains (53%,
Table 3) with a concentration of Ordovician
grains (28.9 %) and a pronounced peak at ~475
Ma. Neoproterozoic zircons are represented by
19.4% of all measured grains, in contrast to
28.2% in sample VN24 from the Van Canh
Formation. Generally, Neoproterozoic zircon
grains are evenly distributed (Table 3), but
show a larger peak at ~963 Ma. The number of
Mesoproterozoic zircon grains in sample VN23
(17.6%) also differs from that of sample VN24
(24.5%). Mesoproterozoic zircons exhibit a
peak at ~1087 Ma but this peak is less promi-
nent in comparison to that at ~1020 Ma in the
sample VN24 (Figures 8, 9). The percentage
distribution of zircon grains with Palaeoprote-
rozoic and Archean ages of both samples are
quite similar, having a peak at ~2500 Ma, but
sample VN23 exhibits a major gap in age in the
Palaeoproterozoic (Figure 9).
Figure 8. Probability diagram of U-Pb ages of detrital
zircons from sample VN24 (Silurian(?) to Early
Devonian Van Canh Formation)
Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences, 39(4), 303-323
317
Figure 9. Probability diagram of U-Pb ages of detrital
zircons from sample VN23 (Middle Devonian Van
Huong Formation)
5. Discussion
U-Pb ages of detrital zircons from the in-
vestigated Van Canh Formation (sample
VN24) of the Do Son Peninsula reflect two
main episodes of crustal recycling, at ~407-
480 Ma and ~940-1100 Ma, with minor peaks
at ~537 Ma, ~720 Ma, ~812 Ma, ~1600 Ma,
and ~2500 Ma (Figure 5). In northwestern
Vietnam detrital zircon U-Pb ages from rocks
of the Sin Quyen Formation exhibit major age
peaks in the Neoarchean (2.7-2.0 Ga and 2.2-
2.5 Ga.) as well as in the Palaeoproterozoic
(~1.8 Ga.; Hieu et al., 2012, see also Mydung
et al., 2014). Similar zircon age patterns from
rocks of the Ca Vinh Complex are published
in Nam et al. (2003). Palaeoproterozoic zircon
ages are known from the Phan Si Pan Zone in
northern Vietnam. Anh et al. (2015) report U-
Pb ages for the Deo Khe Granitoids ranging
from 1855-1873 Ma, which are similar to zir-
con ages of 1.85 Ga reported from the Yangze
Block in South China (Zhao and Cawood,
2012).
Intrusive bodies which indicate the exist-
ence of a Caledonian tectonothermal event in
Vietnam are widely distributed. Based on ge-
ochronological U-Pb and 40Ar-39Ar data pub-
lished by Nagy et al. (2001) and Vu Van Tich
(2001), this event was recognized in the Kon-
tum Massif in central Vietnam, were magmat-
ic rocks exhibit U-Pb ages ranging from 450
Ma to 424 Ma. Recently, Hieu et al. (2016)
published zircon age dates of ~430 Ma from
the Dai Loc granitoid complex, Kontum Mas-
sif. Middle Palaeozoic U-Pb ages of intrusive
rocks are also reported from the Thien Ke
granite pluton in the Tam Dao region (Nguyen
et al., 2014) and the Song Chay area (Roger et
al., 2000; Yan et al., 2006).
Relative probability plots for zircon ages
of the Van Canh Formation (sample VN24,
Figure 8) are similar to those from samples
collected from the NE Vietnam Terrane which
have major peaks at ~440 Ma, ~944 Ma and
~980 Ma and a minor peak at ~2400 Ma, as
well as samples from the Ailaoshan Terrane,
in southern China (Burrett et al., 2014; see
Figure 10). According to these authors, the
zircon peak of 800 Ma (Sibao orogeny) is
weakly developed in NE Vietnam. This peak
was less prominent in the sample of the Van
Canh Formation (sample VN24; Figures 8, 10)
and is absent in the overlying Van Huong
Formation (sample VN23), as shown in Fig-
ures 8-10, thus confirming the results pub-
lished of Burrett et al. (2014). In South
Cathaysia, detrital zircons exhibit a wide age
spectrum, but it is important to note that they
also cluster in two age peaks, at ~970 Ma and
at ~2500 Ma (Yu et al., 2009) which is similar
to the zircon spectrum presented in our study.
Königshof P., et al./Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences 39 (2017)
318
Figure 10. Relative probability plots of terranes and areas discussed in this study: Number (1) Ailaoshan Terrane
(southern China), (2) Tethyan Himalaya, (3) Cathaysia Terrane (4) NE Vietnam from Burrett et al. (2014), (5) Van
Canh Formation, Do Son Peninsula, Vietnam (this study), (6) Van Huong Formation, Do Son Peninsula, Vietnam
(this study)
Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences, 39(4), 303-323
319
Zhu et al. (2011) reported that the presence
or absence of younger (~950 Ma) or older
Grenvillian (~1170 Ma) detrital zircons can be
used to discriminate whether the blocks are
derived from Indian or Australian margins.
Whereas the younger Grenvillian zircons orig-
inated from the Tethyan Himalaya, the older
Grenvillian zircons are derived from the Al-
bany-Fraser belt in southwestern Australia
(Zhu et al., 2011). The presence of younger
Grenvillian zircons in the Van Canh For-
mation (VN24) supports the postulated posi-
tion of NE Vietnam close to the western
Himalaya. A few 2280-2377 Ma zircon grains
are characterized by pale rims depleted in
uranium, which were derived from rocks that
underwent high pressure metamorphic condi-
tions. Himalayan Palaeoproterozoic rocks
could be the source area and angular to-well-
rounded zircons in our samples suggest at
least moderate transport distances.
U-Pb ages of detrital zircons from the
Middle Devonian Van Huong Formation
show a major peak at ~406-475 Ma and
smaller peaks at ~963 Ma, ~1087 Ma, and a
small Palaeoproterozoic input at ~2500 Ma.
The latter peak is also known from sample
VN24 (Figures 8, 9). A possible source for
this zircon peak may be associated with the
Wutai orogeny, an event that is also known in
the Tethyan Himalaya, Cathaysia, India, and
Africa (Yu et al., 2009; Condie et al., 2009;
Wan et al., 2011; Burrett et al., 2014).
According to Squire et al. (2006), the den-
udation of highlands that were formed during
the Pan African and older orogenies were re-
sponsible for the detrital sediment transport
across Gondwana. The age spectrum of zircon
grains in sample VN24 (Lower Devonian Van
Canh Formation) exhibits Neoproterozoic,
Mesoproterozoic, and Palaeoproterozoic zir-
con grains whereas the overlying sample
VN23 (Middle Devonian Van Huong For-
mation) shows a major gap in the Palaeoprote-
rozoic record (Figures 9, 10). This might be a
result of reduced denudation, changing fluvial
flow directions and/or slightly changing pal-
aeogeographic position of northeast Vietnam.
The youngest zircon of each formation
provides maximum ages of sedimentation at
407.1 ± 9.5 Ma and 406.3 ± 4.0 Ma, which are
in general agreement with the palaeontologi-
cal data from the Middle Devonian Van
Huong and the Early Devonian Van Canh
Formations. Facies development and faunal
similarities can also provide constraints on the
palaeogeographic position of NE Vietnam.
According to Xun et al. (1996), Lower Devo-
nian sediments adjacent to the Huanan Land-
mass are characterized by a wide range of
shallow-water to alluvial facies settings. Simi-
lar facies settings are known from northeast
Vietnam. The assumed palaeogeographic po-
sition of NE Vietnam in the Early and Middle
Devonian close to the western Himalayas is
most likely due to faunal similarities between
Vietnam and southern China (Janvier and Ta
Hoa, 1999; Janvier and Tong-Dzuy, 1988;
Jones et al. 1997). Based on vertebrates, os-
tracods, and brachiopods there is likely a pal-
aeobiogeographic relation between the East
Red River region in Vietnam and southern
China. Racheboeuf et al. (2005) describe bey-
richiids and leperditids from NE Vietnam (Ha
Giang Province) which closely resembles
forms from the Silurian and Devonian of the
Yunnan Province of South China. Further-
more, the vertebrate fauna of NE Vietnam and
South China is also similar (Janvier and Ta
Hoa, 1999). The Silurian part of the Do Son
Group (lower part of the Van Canh Formation)
on the Do Son Island contains fish remains
which can be related to primitive antiarchs that
are morphologically close to species reported
from the Late Silurian and Early Devonian in
China (Janvier and Tong-Dzuy, 1988). The
overlying Middle Devonian Van Huong For-
mation of the section shows comparable fau-
nal elements and exhibits similar fluviodeltaic
facies settings comparable to Givetian to Late
Königshof P., et al./Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences 39 (2017)
320
Devonian sediments along the southeastern
coast of China (Long et al., 1990; Lee, 1991;
Jones et al., 1997).
6. Conclusions
Detrital zircons from two Devonian
siliciclastic rocks, the Van Canh and the Van
Huong Formations from the Do Son Peninsu-
lar (NE Vietnam) were analyzed for U, Th,
and Pb isotopes by LA-SF ICP-MS tech-
niques. The youngest zircon of each formation
exhibits maximum ages of sedimentation at
407.1±9.5 Ma (Van Canh Formation) and
406.3±4.0 Ma (Van Huong Formation) which
confirms published biostratigraphic age data.
The zircon cluster of both samples from the
east Red River Basin as well as palaeontologi-
cal affinities to South China, confirms recon-
structions for NE Vietnam close to the west-
ern Himalayas suggested by earlier studies.
Acknowledgements
The paper is a contribution to IGCP 596-
Climate Change and Biodiversity Patterns in
the Mid-Paleozoic (Early Devonian to Late
Carboniferous). Funding by the first-author
(P.K.) is acknowledged by the Deutsche For-
schungsgemeinschaft (DFG Project KO-
1622/15-1). We thank both anonymous re-
viewers for their constructive comments
which helped to improve the manuscript. We
also thank Prof. Sarah K. Carmichael (Appa-
lachian State University, Boone, USA) for
checking the English of the final version. Jana
Anger (Senckenberg - Research Institute and
Natural History Museum Frankfurt) is
thanked for preparing some figures.
References
Anh H.T.H., Hieu P.T., Le Tu V., Choi S.H. and Yu Y.,
2015. Age and tectonic implications of Paleoprote-
rozoic Deo Khe Granitoids within the Phan Si Pan
Zone, Vietnam. Journal of Asian Earth Scienc-
es, 111, 781-791.
Braddy S.J., Seldon P.A., Doan Nhat T., 2002. A new
carcinosomatid eurypterid from the Upper Silurian
of northern Vietnam. Palaeontology, 45, 897-915.
Burrett C., 1974. Plate tectonics and the fusion of Asia.
Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 21, 181-189.
Burrett C. and Stait B., 1985. South East Asia as a part
of Ordovician Gondwanaland-a palaeobiogeographic
test of a tectonic hypothesis. Earth and Planetary
Science Letters, 75, 184-190.
Burrett C. and Stait B., 1987. China and Southeast Asia
as part of the Tethyan margin of Cambro-Ordovician
Gondwanaland. In: McKenzie, K. (Ed.), Shallow
Tethys, 2. Balkema, Rotterdam, 65-77.
Burrett C., Long J. and Stait B., 1990. Early-Middle Pal-
aeozoic biogeography of Asian terranes derived
from Gondwana. In: McKerrow, W., Scotese, C.
(Eds.), Palaeozoic Palaeogeography and Biogeogra-
phy. Geological Society Memoir, 12, 163-174.
Burrett C., Duhig N., Berry R. and Varne R., 1991.
Asian and south-western Pacific continental terranes
derived from Gondwana and their biogeographic
significance. Australian Systematic Botany, 4,
13-24.
Burrett C., Zaw K., Meffre S., Lai C.K., Khositanont S.,
Chaodumrong P., Udchachon M., Ekins S. and Hal-
pin J., 2014. The Configuration of Greater Gondwa-
na - Evidence from LA ICPMS, U-Pb geochronolo-
gy of detrital zircons from the Palaeozoic
and Mesozoic of Southeast Asia and
China. Gondwana Research, 26, 31-51.
Condie K., Belousova E., Griffin W. and Sircombe K.,
2009. Granitoid events in space and time:
constraints from igneous and detrital zircon
age spectra. Gondwana Research, 15, 228-242.
Faure M., Lepvier C., Nguyen V.V., Vu T.V., Lin W.
and Chen Z., 2014. The South China block-
Indochina collision: Where, when, and how? Journal
of Asian Earth Sciences, 79, 260-274.
Findlay R.H., 1997 The Song Ma anticlinorium, north-
ern Vietnam: the structure of an allochthonous ter-
rane containing an early Paleozoic island arc se-
quence. Journal of Asian Earth Sciences, 15,
453-464.
Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences, 39(4), 303-323
321
Gerdes A. and Zeh A., 2006. Combined U-Pb and Hf
isotope LA-(MC-) ICP-MS analysis of detrital zir-
cons: comparison with SHRIMP and new constraints
for the provenance and age of an Armorican
metasediment in Central Germany. Earth and Plane-
tary Science Letters, 249, 47-61.
Hall R., 2009. The Eurasia SE Asian margin as a mod-
ern example of an accretionary orogen. In: Cawood,
P.A., Kroner, A. (Eds.), Earth Accretionary Systems
in Space and Time. The Geological Society London,
Special Publications, 318, 351-372.
Helmcke D., 1985. The Permo-Triassic “Paleotethys” in
mainland Southeast Asia and adjacent parts of
China. Geologische Rundschau, 74, 215-228.
Hieu P.T., Chen F., Me L.T., Thuy N.T.B., Siebel W.
and Lan T.G., 2012. Zircon U-Pb ages and Hf iso-
topic compositions from the Sin Quyen Formation:
the Precambrian crustal evolution of northwest
Vietnam. International Geology Review, 54(13),
1548-1561.
Hieu P.T., Dung N.T., Thuy N.T.B., Minh N.T. and
Pham M.I.N.H., 2016. U=Pb ages and Hf isotopic
composition of zircon and bulk rock geochemistry of
the Dai Loc granitoid complex in Kontum massif:
Implications for early Paleozoic crustal evolution in
Central Vietnam. Journal of Mineralogical and Pet-
rological Sciences, 111(5), 326-336.
Horstwood M.S.A., Košler J., Gehrels G., Jackson S.E.,
McLean N.M., Paton C., Pearson N.J., Sircombe K.,
Sylvester P., Vermeesch P., Bowring J.F., Condon
D.J. and Schoene, B., 2016. Community-derived
standards for LA-ICP-MS U-Th-Pb geochronology -
uncertainty propagation, age interpretation and data
reporting. Geostand Geoanalytical Research, 40,
311-332.
Jackson S., Pearson N.J., Griffin W.L. and Belousova
E.A., 2004. The application of laser ablation-
inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry to in
situ U-Pb zircon geochronology. Chemical Geology,
211, 47-69.
Janvier P., Blieck A., Gerrienne P. and Tong-Dzuy T.,
1987. Faune et flore de la Formation de Sika (De-
vonien inferieur) dans la peninsule de Do Son (Viet
Nam). Bulletin du Museum National d’Histoire Na-
turelle Paris, 9, 291-301.
Janvier P., Racheboeuf P., Nguyen Huu H. and Doan
Nhat T., 2003. Devonian fish (Placodermi, Antiar-
cha) from the Tra Ban Island (Bai Tu Long Bay,
Quang Ninh, Vietnam) and the question of the age
of the Do Son Formation. Journal of Asian Earth
Sciences, 21, 795-801.
Janvier P. and Ta Hoa P., 1999. Les Vertebres (Placo-
dermi, Galeaspida) du Devonien inferieur de la
coupe de Lung Co-Mia Le, province de Ha Giang.
Vietnam, avec des donnees complementaires sur les
gisements a Vertebres du Devonien du Bac Bo
oriental. Geodiversitas, 21, 33-67.
Janvier P. and Tong-Dzuy T., 1998. The Silurian and
Devonian vertebrates of Vietnam: a review. Journal
of Geology (Hanoi), B11, 12, 18-28.
Jones N.S., Fyfe J.A., Sewell R.T., Lai K.W. and Lee
C.M., 1997. Devonian fluviodeltaic sedimentation in
Hong Kong. Journal of Asian Earth Sciences, 15(6),
533-545.
Komatsu T., Kato S., Hirata K., Takashima R., Orata Y.,
Oba M., Naruse H., Tha Hoa P., Nguyen P.D., Dang
H.T., Doan T.N., Nguyen H.H., Sakata S., Kaiho K.
and Königshof P., 2014. Devonian-Carboniferous
transition containing a Hangenberg Black Shale
equivalent in the Pho Han Formation on Cat Ba
Island, northeastern Vietnam. Palaeogeography,
Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 404, 30-43.
10.1016/j.palaeo.2014.03.021.
Königshof P., Narkiewicz K., Phuong Ta Hoa, Carmi-
chael S. and Waters J., 2017. Events in the mid-
Paleozoic: Examples from the eastern Paleotethys
(Si Phai section, NE Vietnam). In: Mottequin B.,
Slavik L., Königshof P. (eds.) Climate change and
biodiversity patterns in the mid-Palaeozoic - Pro-
ceedings-Volume IGCP 596/SDS Meeting Brussels
(2015). Palaeobiodiversity and Palaeoenvironments,
97(3), 481-496.
017-0272-5.
Lantenois H., 1907. Note sur la Géologie de l’Indochine.
Mémoires de la Société Géologique de France, 4,
1-56.
Lee C.M., 1991. The discovery of Devonian Placodermi
in Hong Kong and its significance. In: Chang M.M.,
Liu Y.H., Zhang G.R. (Eds.). Early Vertebrates and
Related Problems of Evolutionary Biology. Science
Press, Beijing, 131-138.
Königshof P., et al./Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences 39 (2017)
322
Lepvrier C., Faure M., Nguyen Van V., Van Vu T., Lin
W., Ta Trong T. and Ta Hoa P., 2011. North-
directed Triassic nappes in Northeastern Vietnam
(East Bac Bo). Journal of Asian Earth Sciences, 41,
56-68.
Long J.A., Burrett C., Pham Kim N. and Janvier P.,
1990. A new bothriolepid antiarch (Pisces, Placo-
dermi) from the Devonian of Do Son Peninsula,
northern Vietnam. Alcheringa, 14, 181-194.
Ludwig K.R., 2001. Users Manual for Isoplot/Ex rev.
2.49: Berkeley Geochronology Center Special Pub-
lication, No.1a, 1-56.
Metcalfe I., 1984. Stratigraphy, palaeontology and pal-
aeogeography of the Carboniferous of Southeast
Asia. Mémoires Société Géologiques France (New
Series), 147, 107-118.
Metcalfe I., 1998. Palaeozoic and Mesozoic geological
evolution of the SE Asian region: multidisziplinary
constraints and implications for biogeography. In:
Hall R., Holloway J.D. (Eds.), Biogeography and
Geological Evolution of SE Asia. Backhuys Pub-
lishers, Leiden, The Netherlands, 25-41.
Metcalfe I., 2006. Palaeozoic and Mesozoic tectonic
evolution and Palaeogeography of East Asian crustal
fragments: the Korean Penninsula in context. Gond-
wanan Research, 9, 24-46.
Metcalfe I., 2011. Tectonic framework and Phanerozoic
evolution of Sundaland. Gondwana Research, 19,
3-21.
Morley C.K., Ampaiwan P., Thanudamrong S.,
Kuenphan N. and Warren J., 2013. Development of
the Khao Kwang Fold and thrust belt: implications
for the geodynamic setting of Thailand and
Cambodia during the Indosinian Orogeny.
Journal of Asian Earth Sciences, 62, 705-719.
My Dung Tran, Junlai L.I.U., Xiaochun L.I. and My
Cung Dang., 2016. Geology, Fluid Inclusion and
Isotopic Study of the Neoproterozoic Suoi Thau
Copper Deposit, Northwest Vietnam. Acta Geologi-
ca Sinica (English Edition), 90(3), 913-927.
Nagy E.A., Maluski H., Lepvrier Q., Scharer U., Thi
P.T. and Leyreloup A., 2001. Geodynamic signifi-
cance of the Kontum Massif in Central Vietnam:
Composite 40Ar-39Ar and U/Pb ages from the Palae-
ozoic to Triassic. Journal of Geology, 109, 755-770.
Nam T.N., 1995. The Geology of Vietnam: A brief
summary and problems. Geoscientific Reports,
Shizuoka University, 1-10.
Nam T.N., Toriumi M., Sano Y., Terada K. and Thang
T.T., 2003. 2.9, 2.36, and 1.96 Ga zircons in or-
thogneiss south of the Red River shear zone in Viet
Nam: evidence from SHRIMP U-Pb dating and tec-
tonothermal implications. Journal of Asian Earth
Sciences, 21(7), 743-753.
Nguyen T.T.B., Hieu P.T., Hai T.T., Xuan N.T. and
Cung D.M., 2014. Petrogenesis and zircon U-Pb ag-
es of the Thien Ke granitic pluton in the Tam Dao
region: Implications for early Paleozoic tectonic
evolution in NE Vietnam. Journal of Mineralogical
and Petrological Sciences, 109(5), 209-221.
Nie Y.S., 1991. Paleoclimate and paleomagnetic con-
straints on the Paleozoic reconstructions of South
China, North China and Tarim. Tectonophysics,
196, 279-309.
Ogg J.G., Ogg G.M. and Gradstein F.M., 2016. A
concise geologic time scale. Elsevier: 1-234.
Racheboeuf P.R., Janvier P., Ta Hoa P., Vannier J. and
Wang S.-Q., 2005. Lower Devonian vertebrates, ar-
thropods and brachiopods from northern Vietnam.
Geobios, 38, 533-551.
Roger F., Leloup P.H., Jolivet M., Lacassin R., Trinh
P.T., Brunel M. and Seward D., 2000. Long and
complex thermal history of the Song Chay meta-
morphic dome (Northern Vietnam) by multi-system
geochronology. Tectonophysics, 321, 449-466.
Sengör A.M.C., Altiner D., Cin A., Ustaomer T. and
Hsu K.J., 1988. Origin and assembly of the Te-
thyside orogenic collage at the expense of Gondwa-
na Land. In: Audley Charles, M.G., Hallam, A.
(Eds.), Gondwana and Tethys. Geological Society of
London, Special Publications, 37, 119-181.
Sircombe K.N., 2004. AGE DISPLAY: an EXCEL
workbook to evaluate and display univariate geo-
chronological data using binned frequency histo-
grams and probability density distributions. Com-
puters & Geosciences, 30, 21-31.
Sláma J., Košler J., Condon D.J., Crowley J.L., Gerdes
A., Hanchar J.M., Horstwood M.S.A., Morris G.A.,
Nasdala L., Norberg N., Schaltegger U., Schoene B.,
Tubrett M.N. and Whitehouse M.J., 2008. Plešovice
Vietnam Journal of Earth Sciences, 39(4), 303-323
323
zircon - A new natural reference material for U-Pb
and Hf isotopic microanalysis. Chemical Geology,
249, 1-35.
Sone M. and Metcalfe I., 2008. Parallel Tethyan sutures
in mainland Southeast Asia: new insights for the
Palaeo-Tethys closure and implications for the In-
dosinian Orogeny. Comptes Rendu Geoscience, 340,
166-179.
Squire R., Campbell I., Allen C. and Wilson C., 2006.
Did the Transgondwanan Supermountain trigger the
explosive radiation of animals on Earth? Earth and
Planetary Sciences Letters, 250, 116-133.
Stacey J.S. and Kramers J.D., 1975. Approximation of
terrestrial lead isotope evolution by a two-stage
model. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 26,
207-221.
Tapponnier P., Lacassin R., Leloup P.H., Scharer U.,
Zhong D., Wu H., Liu X., Ji S., Zhang L. and Zhong
J., 1990. The Ailao Shan - Red River metamorphic
belt: Tertiary left lateral shear between Sundaland
and South China. Nature, 343, 431-437.
Tong-Dzuy, T. (Ed.), 1986. The Devonian of Vietnam.
Science and Technics Publishing House, Hanoi,
141p (in Vietnamese).
Tong-Dzuy T., Janvier P., Doan Nhat T. and Braddy S.,
1994. New vertebrate remains associated with eu-
rypterids from the Devonian Do Son Formation.
Geology (Vietnamese), Hanoi, A, 224, 1-11.
Torsvik T. and Cocks R., 2009. The Lower Palaeozoic
palaeogeographical evolution of the northeastern and
eastern peri-Gondwanan margin from Turkey to
New Zealand. In: Bassett, M. (Ed.), Early Palaeozo-
ic Peri-Gondwana Terranes: New Insights from
Tectonics and Biogeography. Geological Society,
London Special Publications, 325, 3-21.
0305-8719/09/.
Tri T.V. and Khuc V. (Eds.), 2011. Geology and Earth
Resources of Viet Nam. Ministry of Nature Re-
sources and Environment. General Department of
Geology and Minerals of Vietnam, 634p.
Ueno K. and Charoentitirat T., 2011. Carboniferous and
Permian. In: Ridd M., Barber A., Crow M. (Eds.),
The Geology of Thailand. Geological Society,
London, 71-136.
Usuki T., Lan C.-Y., Wang K-L. and Chiu H.-Y., 2013.
Linking the Indochina block and Gondwana during
the Early Paleozoic: Evidence from U-Pb ages and
Hf isotopes of detrital zircons. Tectonophysics, 586,
145-159.
Vu Van Tich, 2001. Petrologie et Geochronologie Ar-Ar
du Bloc de Kontum (Vietnam). DEA University,
Montpelier, p40.
Wan Y., Liu D., Wang W., Song T., Kroner A., Dong
C., Zhou H. and Yin X., 2011. Provenance of Meso-
Neo Proteroizoic cover sediments at the Ming
Tombs, Beijing, North China Craton: an integrated
study of U-Pb dating and Hf isotopic measurement
of detrital zircons and whole rock geochemistry.
Gondwana Research, 20, 219-242.
Xun Z., Allen M.B., Whitham A.G. and Price S.P.,
1996. Rift-related Devonian sedimentation and basin
development in South China. Journal of Southeast
Asian Earth Sciences, 14(1/2), 37-52.
Yan D.P., Zhou M.F. and Wang Y.C., 2006. Structural
and geochronological constraints on the Dulong-
Song Chay tectonic dome in SE Yunnan (SW China)
and northern Vietnam. Journal of Asian Earth
Sciences, 28, 332-353.
Yang S.P., Pan K., and Hou H.F., 1981. The Devonian
System in China. Geological magazine, 118(2),
113-224.
Yu J.H., Wang L.J., O`Reilly S.Y., Griffin W.L., Zhang
M., Li C.Z. and Shu L.S., 2009. A Paleoproterozoic
orogeny recorded in a long-lived cratonic remnant
(Wuyishan terrane), eastern Cathaysia Block, China.
Precambrian Research, 174, 347-363.
Zhao G.C. and Cawood P.A., 2012. Precambrian Geolo-
gy of China. Precambrian Research, 222(223),
13-54.
Zhao X., Allen M.B., Whitham A.G. and Price S.M.,
1996. Rift-related Devonian sedimentation and basin
development in South China. Journal of Southeast
Asian Earth Sciences, 14(1/2), 37-52.
Zhu D.C., Zhao Z.D., Niu Y.L., Dilek Y. and Mo X.X.,
2011. Lhasa terrane in southern Tibet came from
Australia. Geology, 39, 727-730.
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
- 10727_39669_1_pb_6202_2090308.pdf