Conclusions and recommendation
Lowland rice consumes much more water than any other
crops. Although this study is based on a rough water balance
equation that only uses three places (i.e. An Giang, Can Tho
and Soc Trang) along the Hau river, the calculated results
show that it is impossible to satisfy this huge water amount
for the irrigation of all the rice areas in the Mekong river
delta in Vietnam during the dry seasons.
There are many future uncertainties for which scenariobased studies might be required. For example, increasing
air temperature, higher solar radiation, stronger wind
velocity, less precipitation distribution, extended drought
and salinity duration, as well as the effects of present and
future agricultural transformation are main factors affecting
rice planting areas and the growth of rice. Rice and other
crop productivity can be damaged by an increasing scarcity
of water resources for irrigation in the future.
When the extreme scenario of historical drought and
salinity intrusion occurred in 2016, the cultivation areas
in the MD were narrowed down by more than 35.5%.
if upstream countries continue to develop their megairrigation projects with 3-fold larger irrigated areas than
what exists currently, the water supply capacity for rice and
upland crops in the delta will decrease dramatically.
in view of economic and social aspects, rice farmers in
the Delta will pay more money to pump water when the water
level and flow discharge of the Mekong River decreases.
Accordingly, their income will be further reduced as a
consequence of climate change, water diversion, as well as
abnormal operation of hydropower dam projects. The rice
production areas must be reduced as what has already been
elaborated in resolution 120 of the Government of Vietnam
because water and food security for the downstream nations
will be threated.
Water for farming should be used as efficiently as
possible; the water productivity (crop per drop) should
increase and the water profitability (income per litre) should
also be increased by switching from rice to high-value crops.
The development of water saving methods for farmers in
parallel with farming systems improvement and cropping
patterns adjustment is strongly recommended. Furthermore,
strategic solutions on hydro-diplomacy and the legal and
institutional aspects of water resource governance on
international, regional, and local scales should be promoted
to share both water benefits and risks among all the Mekong
countries.
6 trang |
Chia sẻ: hachi492 | Lượt xem: 6 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem nội dung tài liệu Water balance for agriculture production in the dry seasons of the Mekong river delta in Viet Nam, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
Life ScienceS | Agriculture
Vietnam Journal of Science,
Technology and Engineering56 September 2020 • Volume 62 Number 3
Background
The Vietnamese Mekong river delta (MD) is the largest
wetland region in the southernmost part of the Mekong river
basin and connects more than 700 km of coastal line to the
East Sea and the Gulf of Thailand (Fig. 1). The Delta is four
million ha in size (12% of total natural land of Vietnam)
and hosts more than 18 million inhabitants (about 22% of
the entire country’s population in 2009). For more than
300 years, the local people have lived close to rivers and
streams to facilitate the domestic use of water, such as for
agricultural cultivation, fishery, and river transportation.
Thus, any change in the water source affects their activities
and the ecosystem of the area. The MD is recognized as
the largest agriculture and aquaculture production region of
Vietnam. The delta supplies more than 53% of the nation’s
staple food, rice (Fig. 2), 65% of the total fish production,
and 75% of the tropical fruit trees. Further, rice production is
considered to be the main economic sector, which occupies
more than 60% of the labour force in the MD.
The total rice production of Vietnam for the 2014-2015
market year reached 45.18 million tons of paddy rice or
approximately 28.24 million tons of milled rice. Since the
end of the 1980s, Vietnam has been known as one of the
top five milled rice exporters to the world market and more
than 90% of Vietnam’s rice export comes from the MD.
From a series of data obtained from the General Statistical
Office [1], the total rice production in the MD exceeded
25.25 million tons in 2014-2015. in this period, about 7.1
million tons of rice was sold to the world food market,
which became the record for the largest amount of rice
exported from the nation. The cropping calendar for rice
and other upland plant cultivation in the MD, in terms of the
Water balance for agriculture production
in the dry seasons of the Mekong river delta in Vietnam
Le Anh Tuan*
Research Institute for Climate Change - Can Tho University
Received 8 April 2020; accepted 24 July 2020
*Email: latuan@ctu.edu.vn
Abstract:
Water is the most important component of agriculture
production, especially during the dry seasons when
all water sources are scarce yet water needs are very
high. The Mekong river delta in Vietnam is the largest
agricultural and aquacultural region in the country
where about half of the Delta’s land area is used for
rice and upland crop cultivation. One key strategy to
address the regional water utility problem is to estimate
the net water requirement during the dry seasons.
The needs for irrigation water discharge for rice and
other upland crops during the dry seasons of the Delta
were quantified using the Penman-Monteith equation
for estimating reference crop evapotranspiration
along with the CROPWAT model for calculating crop
irrigation water requirements. In general, the total
water taken from the Mekong river flow for irrigation
requirements should be approximately 2,300-2,600
m3/s for normal yields in the current agriculture areas
and under local cultivation conditions. Water diversion
and upstream hydropower projects are challenging
tasks, especially in the context of climate change, to
satisfy the water needs for agricultural irrigation in
the near future. All water stakeholders among the
neighbouring countries that rely on the Mekong river
must adjust their regional water-use planning as one of
the mitigation solutions for the seasonal drought crisis.
Keywords: agriculture, CROPWAT model, irrigation
water, Mekong Delta, water balance.
Classification number: 3.1
Doi: 10.31276/VJSTE.62(3).56-61
Life ScienceS | Agriculture
Vietnam Journal of Science,
Technology and Engineering 57September 2020 • Volume 62 Number 3
growing season duration and the number of crops against
the available water conditions in rainfed and irrigated
areas, is shown in Fig. 3. From the calendar, a very large
water requirement occurs at the end of the dry season, i.e.
March and April. However, in March and April, a majority
of the seasonal rice has been harvested and those fields are
vacated. in a few irrigated areas and saltwater intrusion-free
areas such as the An Giang, Dong Thap, Can Tho, and Vinh
Long provinces, farmers may plough the lands to prepare
for their new rice crop and a lot of water is pumped to the
rice fields in March and April.
Fig. 3. Agricultural cropping calendar in the Vietnamese MD.
Since 2014, locating fresh water sources has become a
huge challenge for agricultural irrigation, especially during
the dry season. The available water flow from the Mekong
river to the delta has seriously dropped resulting in saline
water intrusion of hundreds of thousands of hectares of
rice fields. According to the statistics from the Ministry
of Agriculture and Rural Development [4], the serious
effects of drought and saline intrusion in 2015-2016 caused
damage to more than 339,000 ha of Winter-Spring rice
paddies, which resulted in a nearly 22% loss of total rice
area across the region. Due to limits placed on irrigation
water, the Winter-Spring rice crop area dropped by 8.72%
in 2016 when compared with the rice area in 2014 (Fig. 4).
Fig. 4. Change in the Winter-Spring rice areas in the MD due to
drought and saline intrusion. Data source [1].
Rice is a major food source for not only the Vietnamese
but also for many people around the world. it is well-known
that rice cultivation in the lowlands like the MD requires
copious amounts of water. At the flowering stage of rice
growth, the need for water is high and the rice yield is very
sensitive to water deficit, which results in increased spikelet
sterility and thus fewer grains. Determining the amount
of field water needed to produce one kilogram of rice is a
critical issue for water managers. Many experiences have
shown that there are large variations in the water need, i.e.,
4
limits placed on irrigation wate , the Winter-Spring ric crop area dropped by 8.72% in
2016 when compared with the rice area in 2014 (Fig. 4).
Fig. 4. Change in the Winter-Spring rice areas in the MD due to drought and saline
intrusion. Data source [1].
Rice is a major food source for not only the Vietnamese but also for many people
around the world. It is well-known that rice cultivation in the lowlands like the MD requires
copious amounts of water. At the flowering stage of rice growth, the need for water is high
and the rice yield is very sensitive to water deficit, which results in increased spikelet
sterility and thus fewer grains. Determining the amount of field water needed to produce
one kilogram of rice is a critical issue for water managers. Many experiences have shown
that there are large variations in the water need, i.e., to produce one kilogram of rice, about
3,000-5,000 litres of water is required on average, which greatly depends on farming
management and weather.
In agro-meteorology, evapotranspiration is a word combining evaporation and
transpiration and is one of the most significant components of water balance in crop fields.
On average, it takes 1.432 litres of evapotranspired water to produce 1 kg of rough rice [5].
In reality, the water need may go up to 2,500 litres, which includes the outflows of
evapotranspiration, seepage, and percolation [6]. Water demand for agricultural cultivation
is defined as the amount of water required for crops that compensates for the loss of water
due to evapotranspiration and the physical conditions of the soil and land that contribute to
water storage as well as the growth stages of the crop. Table 1 presents a rough comparison
of water balance for irrigated areas in the countries of the Lower Mekong Basin (LMB)
versus land area, population, and the Mekong River flow discharge available in the dry
season. An estimation of irrigation volume requirements for rice and other upland crops is
considered as a regional water security strategy.
1,488.3
1,564.6
1,562.7
1,531
1,426.3
1400
1420
1440
1460
1480
1500
1520
1540
1560
1580
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
R
ic
e
ar
ea
(x
1
,0
00
h
a)
Fig. 1. The Mekong river delta in Vietnam and the delta’s
network of rivers and canals. Source [2].
3
Fig. 2. Contributions to rice production in Vietnam. Data source [3].
Fig. 3. Agricultural cropping calendar in the Vietnamese MD.
Since 2014, locating fresh water sources has become a huge challenge for
agricultural irrigation, especially during the dry season. The available water flow from the
Mekong River to the Delta has seriously dropped resulting in saline water intrusion of
hundreds of thousands of hectares of rice fields. According to the statistics from the
Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development [4], the serious effects of drought and
saline intrusion in 2015-2016 caused damage to more than 339,000 ha of Winter-Spring rice
paddies, which resulted in a nearly 22% loss of total rice area across the region. Due to
Mekong river
delta 53%
Mekong river
delta 18%
Northern
coastal
region 16%
Central
region
8%
Highland
region 2%
South Eastern region 3%
Fig. 2. Contributions to rice production in Vietnam. Data source
[3].
Life ScienceS | Agriculture
Vietnam Journal of Science,
Technology and Engineering58 September 2020 • Volume 62 Number 3
to produce one kilogram of rice, about 3,000-5,000 litres
of water is required on average, which greatly depends on
farming management and weather.
in agro-meteorology, evapotranspiration is a word
combining evaporation and transpiration and is one of the
most significant components of water balance in crop fields.
on average, it takes 1.432 litres of evapotranspired water
to produce 1 kg of rough rice [5]. in reality, the water need
may go up to 2,500 litres, which includes the outflows of
evapotranspiration, seepage, and percolation [6]. Water
demand for agricultural cultivation is defined as the amount
of water required for crops that compensates for the loss of
water due to evapotranspiration and the physical conditions
of the soil and land that contribute to water storage as
well as the growth stages of the crop. Table 1 presents a
rough comparison of water balance for irrigated areas in
the countries of the Lower Mekong basin (LMB) versus
land area, population, and the Mekong river flow discharge
available in the dry season. An estimation of irrigation
volume requirements for rice and other upland crops is
considered as a regional water security strategy.
Table 1. Land, population and rice production in the Lower
Mekong basin, 2014.
Variable Thailand Laos Cambodia Vietnam Total
Area in LMB (km2 x 103)
Area in LMB (%)
Population in LMB (2014) (x 106)
Population in LMB (2014) (%)
Population density (persons/km2)
Agriculture area in LMB (ha x 103)
Paddy area in LMB (ha x 103)
Paddy are as % of agric. area
irrigated paddy area (ha x 103)
irrigated as % of paddy area
Paddy prod. (2014) (t x 106)
% growth of prod. (2000-2014)
Average yield (2014) (t x 106)
Prod. as % of country’s total
184.0
28.7
24.2
36.7
132
10,300
1,647
45.1
1,425
30.7
14.7
2.5
2.6
45
202.0
31.5
6.1
9.3
28
1,900
631
33.2
172
27.3
3.9
4.5
4.3
98
161.0
25.0
12.5
19.0
78
3,100
1,647
53.1
505
30.7
8.7
6.1
3.1
94
95.0
14.8
23.0
35.0
279
4,610
2,606
56.5
1,921
73.7
25.2
3.0
5.9
56
642.0
100.0
65.8
100.0
103
19,910
6,531
47.9
4,023
42.2
52.5
3.4
3.8
57
Data source [7].
Methodology
CRoPWAT [8] is a decision support system software
developed by the Land and Water Development Division
of the UN’s Food and Agriculture organization for the
calculation of crop water and irrigation requirements based
on soil, climate, and crop data. The equations for the efficient
quantity of crop water are based the guidelines of [9] and
the expected crop yield is based on the water use in [10].
The maximum crop evapotranspiration (ETcrop) is equal to
the reference-crop evapotranspiration (ETo) multiplied by
the crop coefficient (Kc):
ETcrop = Kc x ETo (Eq. 1)
The crop coefficient values, Kc, were provided for a
large number of crops and the procedures to determine
the ETcrop over the growing season were followed. Crop
water requirements are defined by the depth of water
needed to mitigate water loss through maximum crop
evapotranspiration (ETcrop) in order to achieve full production
potentials under the given crop growing environment. The
Penman-Monteith equation is the FAo’s standard method
for modelling evapotranspiration and is formulated as [8]:
5
Table 1: Land, population and rice production in the Lower Mekong Basin, 2014.
Variable Thailand Laos Cambodia Vietnam Total
Area in LMB (km2 x 103)
Area in LMB (%)
Population in LMB (2014) (x 106)
Population in LMB (2014) (%)
Population density (persons/km2)
Agriculture area in LMB (ha x 103)
Paddy area in LMB (ha x 103)
Paddy are as % of agric. area
irrigated paddy area (ha x 103)
irrigated as % of paddy area
Paddy prod. (2014) (t x 106)
% growth of prod. (2000-2014)
Average yield (2014) (t x 106)
Prod. as % of country’s total
184.0
28.7
24.2
36.7
132
10,300
1647
45.1
1425
30.7
14.7
2.5
2.6
45
202.0
31.5
6.1
9.3
28
1900
631
33.2
172
27.3
3.9
4.5
4.3
98
161.0
25.0
12.5
19.0
78
3100
1647
53.1
505
30.7
8.7
6.1
3.1
94
95.0
14.8
23.0
35.0
279
4610
2606
56.5
1921
73.7
25.2
3.0
5.9
56
642.0
100.0
65.8
100.0
103
19,910
9531
47.9
4023
42.2
52.5
3.4
3.8
57
Data Source. [7].
Methodology
CRoPWAT [8] is a decision support system software developed by the Land and
Water Development Division of the UN’s Food and Agriculture Organization for the
calculation of crop water and irrigation requirements based on soil, climate, and crop data.
The equations for the efficient quantity of crop water are based the guidelines of [9] and the
expected crop yield is based on the water use in [10]. The maximum crop
evapotranspiration (ETcrop) is equal to the reference-crop evapotranspiration (ETo)
multiplied by the crop coefficient (Kc):
ETcrop = Kc x ETo. (Eq. 1)
The crop coefficient values, Kc, were provided for a large number of crops and the
procedures to determine the ETcrop over the growing season were followed. Crop water
requirements are defin d by the depth of water needed to mitigate water loss through
maximum crop evapotranspiration (ETcrop) in order to achieve full production potentials
under the given crop growing environment. The Penman-Monteith equation is the FAo’s
standard method for modelling evapotranspiration and is formulated as [8]: ( ) ( ) ( ) , (Eq. 2)
where ETo (mm.day-1) is the reference evapotranspiration, Rn (MJ.m-2day-1) is the net
radiation recorded at the crop surface, G (MJ.m-2day-1) is the monitored soil heat flux
density, T (°C) is mean daily air temperature measured at 2 m height, u2 (m.s-1) is the wind
speed measured at 2 m height, es and ea (kPa) are the actual vapor pressure and saturation
(Eq. 2)
where ETo (mm.day-1) is the reference evapotranspiration,
Rn (MJ.m-2 ay-1) is the net radiation recorded at the crop
urface, G (MJ.m-2da -1) is the monitored soil heat flux
density, T (°C) is mean daily air temperature measured at 2
m height, u2 (m.s-1) is the wind speed measured at 2 m height,
es and ea (kPa) are the actual vapor pressure and saturation
vapor pressure such that (es - ea) (kPa) is the saturation
vapor pressure deficit, ∆ (kPa °C-1) is the slope of the vapor
pressure curve, and γ (kPa °C-1) is the psychometric constant.
The water balance equation for a rice field is estimated
by Eq. 3:
6
vapor pressure such that (es - ea) (kPa) is the saturation vapor pressure deficit, (kPa °C-1)
is the slope of the vapor pressure curve, and (kPa °C-1) is the psychometric constant.
The water balance equation for a rice field is estimated by Eq. 3:
iiisdiiiCi CKePmhh 0 (Eq. 3)
where all units are mm, hci is the water depth of the field at the end of calculated period, hoi
is the water depth in the field in the start of calculated period, mi is the irrigated water
during the ith calculated period, Psdi is the possible precipitation used during the ith
calculated period, (ei + Ki) are the water losses during the ith calculated period, and Ci is
the drainage water during the ith calculated period. it is necessary to first have an irrigation
scheme based on Eq. 3 and then the irrigation water volume to each unit of irrigation land
(m3/ha) is estimated.
For estimation of the water requirement for an irrigation scheme, the coefficient of
irrigation (q), defined as the water discharge needed for providing a plant cultivation area
unit, is given in Eq. 4:
ij
ij
iij t
m
q
4,86
, (Eq. 4)
where qij (l.s-1ha-1) is the coefficient of irrigation of the ith plant in the jth irrigation time, i
is the ratio of the area between the ith plant and the entire irrigation area, mij (m3.ha-1) is the
irrigation discharge of the ith plant at the jth irrigation time, and tij (days) is the time for mij
irrigation. Evapotranspiration in the dry season is higher than in the rainy season and the
available water discharge from the Mekong River to the Delta is lower in the dry season,
therefore this paper focuses on the estimation of the water requirement for the Winter-
Spring rice crop.
in this study, the meteorological data for a 10-year series of water requirement
calculations are collected from the Provincial Weather Stations of An Giang, Can Tho, and
Soc Trang which serve as three rice production regions that represent the flood plain areas,
middle areas, and coastal areas, respectively. Hydrological data for water balance analysis
during the dry seasons are collected from the Mekong River Commission [10, 11]. The
monthly discharge from the hydrological stations of the Lower Mekong mainstream from
Chiang Sean (in Thailand) to Luang Prabang, Vientiane, Nakhon Phanom, Mukdahan and
Pakse (all in Laos) and Kratie (in Cambodia) is presented in Table 2. The mean monthly
discharge flows at Tan Chau and Chau Doc (in Vietnam) are available over the period
1979-1996 as presented in Table 3. The soil texture groups of the surveyed fields are from
the Provincial Department of Agriculture and Rural Development. other secondary data,
such as reports, papers, and irrigation water utility events from the upstream countries of the
Mekong Basin are reviewed for discussion [12-19].
(Eq. 3)
where all units are mm, hci is the water depth of the field
at the end of calculated period, hoi is the water depth in the
field in the start of calculated period, Σmi is the irrigated
water during the ith calculated period, ΣPsdi is the possible
precipitation used during th ith calculated p riod, Σ(ei +
Ki) are the water losses during the ith calculated per od, and
ΣCi is the drainage water during the th calculated period.
It is necessary to first have an irrigation scheme based on
Eq. 3 and then the irrigation water volume to each unit of
irrigation land (m3/ha) is stimated.
For estimation of the water requirement for an irrigation
scheme, the coefficient of irrigation (q), defined as the water
discharge needed for providing a plant cultivation area unit,
is given in Eq. 4:
6
vapor pressure such that (es - ea) (kPa) is the saturation vapor pressure deficit, (kPa °C-1)
is the slope of the vapor pressure curve, and (kPa °C-1) is the psychometric constant.
The water b lance equation for rice field is estimated by Eq. 3:
iiisdiiiCi CKePmhh 0 (Eq. 3)
where all units are mm, hci is the water depth of the field at the end of calculated period, hoi
is the water depth in the field in the start of calculated period, mi is the irrigated water
during the ith calculated period, Psdi is the possible precipitation used during the ith
calculated period, (ei + Ki) are the water losses during the ith calculated period, and Ci is
the drainage water during the ith calculated period. it is necessary to first have an irrigation
scheme based on Eq. 3 and then the irrigation water volume to each unit of irrigation land
(m3/ha) is estimated.
For estimation of the water requirement for an irrigation scheme, the coefficient of
irrigation (q), defined as the water discharge needed for providing a plant cultivation area
unit, is given in Eq. 4:
ij
ij
iij t
m
q
4,86
, (Eq. 4)
where qij (l.s-1ha-1) is the coefficient of irrigation of the ith plant in the jth irrigation time, i
is the ratio of the area between the ith plant and the entire irrigation area, mij (m3.ha-1) is the
irrigation discharge of the ith plant at the jth irrigation time, and tij (days) is the time for mij
irrigation. Evapotranspiration in the dry season is higher than in the rainy season and the
available water discharge from the Mekong River to the Delta is lower in the dry season,
therefore this paper focuses on the estimation of the water requirement for the Winter-
Spring rice crop.
in this study, the meteorological data for a 10-year series of water requirement
calculations are collected from the Provincial Weather Stations of An Giang, Can Tho, and
Soc Trang which serve as three rice production regions that represent the flood plain areas,
middle areas, and coastal areas, respectively. Hydrological data for water balance analysis
during the dry seasons are collected from the Mekong River Commission [10, 11]. The
monthly discharge from the hydrological stations of the Lower Mekong mainstream from
Chiang Sean (in Thailand) to Luang Prabang, Vientiane, Nakhon Phanom, Mukdahan and
Pakse (all in Laos) and Kratie (in Cambodia) is presented in Table 2. The mean monthly
discharge flows at Tan Chau and Chau Doc (in Vietnam) are available over the period
1979-1996 as presented in Table 3. The soil texture groups of the surveyed fields are from
the Provincial Department of Agriculture and Rural Development. other secondary data,
such as reports, papers, and irrigation water utility events from the upstream countries of the
Mekong Basin are reviewed for discussion [12-19].
(Eq. 4)
where qij (l.s-1ha-1) is the coefficient of irrigation of the ith
plan in the jth irrigation time, αi is the r tio of the area
between the ith plant and the e tire irrigation area, mij ( 3.
ha-1) is the irrigation d scharge of the ith plant at the jth
irrigation time, and tij (days) is the time for mij irrigation.
Evapo rans iration in the dry s ason is higher an in
Life ScienceS | Agriculture
Vietnam Journal of Science,
Technology and Engineering 59September 2020 • Volume 62 Number 3
the rainy season and the available water discharge from
the Mekong river to the delta is lower in the dry season,
therefore this paper focuses on the estimation of the water
requirement for the Winter-Spring rice crop.
in this study, the meteorological data for a 10-year
series of water requirement calculations are collected from
the provincial ưeather stations of An Giang, Can Tho, and
Soc Trang which serve as three rice production regions that
represent the flood plain areas, middle areas, and coastal
areas, respectively. Hydrological data for water balance
analysis during the dry seasons are collected from the
Mekong river commission [10, 11]. The monthly discharge
from the hydrological stations of the Lower Mekong
mainstream from Chiang Saen (in Thailand) to Luang
Prabang, Vientiane, Nakhon Phanom, Mukdahan and Pakse
(all in Laos) and Kratie (in Cambodia) is presented in Table
2. The mean monthly discharge flows at Tan Chau and Chau
Doc (in Vietnam) are available over the period 1979-1996 as
presented in Table 3. The soil texture groups of the surveyed
fields are from the Provincial Department of Agriculture and
Rural Development. other secondary data, such as reports,
papers, and irrigation water utility events from the upstream
countries of the Mekong Basin are reviewed for discussion
[12-19].
Table 3. Mean monthly flows at Tan Chau (TC) and Chau Doc
(CD) Stations (m3.s-1).
St. Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. May. Jun. Jul. Aug. Sep. Oct. Nov. Dec.
TC 6,220 3,720 2,600 2,010 2,640 7,180 11,270 16,390 21,140 20,340 15,260 10,180
CD 1,360 700 420 330 460 1,450 2,390 3,970 5,200 5,480 4,700 2,710
Tot. 7,580 4,420 3,020 2,340 3,100 8,630 13,660 20,360 25,430 25,820 19,960 12,800
Data source [12].
Results and discussion
Based on the Penman-Monteith equation (Eq. 2), the
reference evapotranspiration ETo calculation results of An
Giang, Can Tho, and Soc Trang provinces during the dry
seasons are given in Table 4.
Table 4. The reference evapotranspiration in ETo (mm/day) for
6 months of the dry seasons (data taken from 2008-2017).
Province/city Nov. Dec. Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr.
An Giang 3.27 3.04 3.28 4.48 5.43 5.82
Can Tho 3.35 3.16 3.43 4.39 5.21 5.73
Soc Trang 3.32 3.08 3.36 4.35 5.06 5.62
Based on the water balance equations, results from
calculated irrigation rate from CRoWAT for the Winter-
Spring rice crop is 9,500±400 m3ha-1 and the coefficient
of irrigation is in the range of 1.36-1.39 l.s-1ha-1. When
compared with the Vietnamese Standards (TCVN 8641-
2011) for the Winter-Spring rice crop in the southern region
of Vietnam, the irrigation rate during growing periods should
be from 7,500 to 8,000 m3ha-1 [20], excluding the irrigation
rate for the land preparation period, which is about 900-
1,000 m3ha-1. The higher calculated irrigation rate can be
explained by the higher air temperature in combination with
stronger air-wind speeds over the last 10 years resulting in
higher evapotranspiration rates, which provides evidence of
water insecurity compounded by climate variability.
For other agriculture products (upland crops, aquaculture,
and animal husbandry), the water needs are experimentally
estimated to be 30-35% [19] of the water amount for rice
Table 2. Lower Mekong mainstream monthly discharge 1960 to 2004 (m3.s-1).
Sites
Month
Mainstream sites
Chiang Saen Luang Prabang Vientiane Nakhon Phanom Mukdahan Pakse Kratie
January 1,150 1,690 1,760 2,380 2,370 2,800 3,620
February 930 1,280 1,370 1,860 1,880 2,170 2,730
March 830 1,060 1,170 1,560 1,600 1,840 2,290
April 910 1,110 1,190 1,530 1,560 1,800 2,220
May 1,300 1,570 1,720 2,410 2,430 2,920 3,640
June 2,460 3,110 3,410 6,610 7,090 8,810 11,200
July 4,720 6,400 6,920 12,800 13,600 16,600 22,200
August 6,480 9,920 11,000 19,100 20,600 26,200 35,500
September 5,510 8,990 10,800 18,500 19,800 26,300 36,700
october 3,840 5,750 6,800 10,200 10,900 15,400 22,000
November 2,510 3,790 4,230 5,410 5,710 7,780 10,900
December 1,590 2,400 2,560 3,340 3,410 4,190 5,710
Data source [11].
Life ScienceS | Agriculture
Vietnam Journal of Science,
Technology and Engineering60 September 2020 • Volume 62 Number 3
cultivation or 594-693 m3ha-1. in general, the total water
taken from the MD’s river system for nearly 1,360,000 ha
agricultural land during the dry season is approximately
2,500-2,600 m3s-1, which is the minimum requirement for
normal yields.
Considering the mean monthly flow discharges of the
Mekong river that passes Pakse (Laos), Kratie (Cambodia),
Tan Chau (Vietnam), and Chau Doc (Vietnam) during the dry
season, it is easy to find that the expected water requirement
for irrigation in the MD is greater than the inflows of the
Mekong mainstream. Thus, this figure indicates that this
water source during the dry season is the greatest limitation
to the extension of cultivation areas not only in the MD but
also to other upstream countries.
Conclusions and recommendation
Lowland rice consumes much more water than any other
crops. Although this study is based on a rough water balance
equation that only uses three places (i.e. An Giang, Can Tho
and Soc Trang) along the Hau river, the calculated results
show that it is impossible to satisfy this huge water amount
for the irrigation of all the rice areas in the Mekong river
delta in Vietnam during the dry seasons.
There are many future uncertainties for which scenario-
based studies might be required. For example, increasing
air temperature, higher solar radiation, stronger wind
velocity, less precipitation distribution, extended drought
and salinity duration, as well as the effects of present and
future agricultural transformation are main factors affecting
rice planting areas and the growth of rice. Rice and other
crop productivity can be damaged by an increasing scarcity
of water resources for irrigation in the future.
When the extreme scenario of historical drought and
salinity intrusion occurred in 2016, the cultivation areas
in the MD were narrowed down by more than 35.5%.
if upstream countries continue to develop their mega-
irrigation projects with 3-fold larger irrigated areas than
what exists currently, the water supply capacity for rice and
upland crops in the delta will decrease dramatically.
in view of economic and social aspects, rice farmers in
the Delta will pay more money to pump water when the water
level and flow discharge of the Mekong River decreases.
Accordingly, their income will be further reduced as a
consequence of climate change, water diversion, as well as
abnormal operation of hydropower dam projects. The rice
production areas must be reduced as what has already been
elaborated in resolution 120 of the Government of Vietnam
because water and food security for the downstream nations
will be threated.
Water for farming should be used as efficiently as
possible; the water productivity (crop per drop) should
increase and the water profitability (income per litre) should
also be increased by switching from rice to high-value crops.
The development of water saving methods for farmers in
parallel with farming systems improvement and cropping
patterns adjustment is strongly recommended. Furthermore,
strategic solutions on hydro-diplomacy and the legal and
institutional aspects of water resource governance on
international, regional, and local scales should be promoted
to share both water benefits and risks among all the Mekong
countries.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This study is partly funded by the Can Tho University
improvement Project VN14-P6, and supported by a
Japanese oDA loan.
The author declares that there is no conflict of interest
regarding the publication of this article.
REFERENCES
[1] General Statistical Office (2016), Statistical Yearbook of
Vietnam, Statistic Publishing House.
[2] S. Benedikter (2014), "Extending the hydraulic paradigm:
reunification, state consolidation and water control in the Vietnamese
Mekong delta after 1975", Southeast Asian Studies, 3(3), pp.547-587.
[3] General Statistical Office (2015), Statistical Yearbook of
Vietnam, Statistic Publishing House.
[4]
drought-and-saltwater-attack-mekong-delta.html.
[5] S.J. Zwart and W.G.M. Bastiaansen (2004), "Reviewed of
measured crop productivity values for irrigated wheat, rice, cotton
and maize", Agric. Water Management, 69, pp.115-133.
[6] FAo irrigation and drainage paper 24 (1977), Crop Water
Requirements, Food and Agriculture organization of the United
Nations, Rome, italy. iSSN 92-5-100279-7.
[7] T.L. Cosslett, P.D. Cosslett (2018), Sustainable Development
of Rice and Water Resources in Mainland Southeast Asia and Mekong
River Basin. Tables 5.2, 5.3, 5.4 and 5.5. Springer Nature, Singapore.
[8] M. Smith (1992), CROPWAT: a computer Programme for
Irrigation Planning and Management, FAo irrigation and Drainage
Paper No. 46, Food and Agriculture organization of the United
Nations, Rome, italy.
Life ScienceS | Agriculture
Vietnam Journal of Science,
Technology and Engineering 61September 2020 • Volume 62 Number 3
[9] R.G. Allen, L.S. Pereira, D. Raes and M. Smith (1998),
Crop Evapotranspiration - Guidelines for Computing Crop Water
Requirements, FAo irrigation and Drainage Paper No.56, Food and
Agriculture organization of the United Nations, Rome, italy.
[10] P. Steduto, C.H. Theodore, F. Elias and R. Dirk (2012), Crop
yield Response to Water, FAo irrigation and Drainage Paper No.66,
Food and Agriculture organization of the United Nations, Rome,
italy.
[11] MRC (2005), Overview of the Hydrology of the Mekong
Basin, MRC, Vientiane, 73pp.
[12] MRC (2009), The Flow of the Mekong, MRC Management
information booklet series No.2. 12pp.
[13] F. Molle (2005), Irrigation and Water Policies in the Mekong
Region: Current Discourses and Practices, Colombo, Sri Lanka:
iWMi, 43pp (Research report 95).
[14] F. Molle and P. Floch (2007), Water, Poverty and the
Governance of Megaprojects: The Thai “Water Grid”, Mekong
Program on Water, institut de Recherche pour le Développement,
international Water Management institute. Chiang Mai, Thailand.
30pp.
[15] F. Molle and P. Floch (2008), The “Desert bloom” Syndrome:
Irrigation Development Politics and Ideology in the Northeast of
Thailand, Mekong Program on Water, institut de Recherche pour le
Développement. international Water Management institute, Chiang
Mai, Thailand, 29pp.
[16] ADB (2011), Lao People’s Democratic Republic: Northern
Community-Managed Irrigation Sector Project, Technical Report,
81pp.
[17] C. Boualapha, o. Philavong (2011), "Water planning in Lao
PDR", Water in the Green Economy in Practice: Toward Rio+20,
Zaragora.
[18] F. Molle, T. Foran and M. Kakonen (2012), Contested
Waterscapes in the Mekong Region: Hydropower, Livelihoods and
Governance, Earthscan publishing, 448pp.
[19] R. Johnston, T. Try and S. Silva (2013), Agricultural Water
Management Planning in Cambodia, WMi - ACiAR investing in
water management to improve Productivity of Rice-Based Farming
systems in Cambodia Project.
[20] MoNRE (2011), TCVN 8641:2011: Hydraulic Structures -
Irrigation and Drainage Techniques for Provisions Crops.
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
water_balance_for_agriculture_production_in_the_dry_seasons.pdf